Doctrine page

Reasoned Orders

Must the Controller give reasons when refusing a patent application?

Under section 15, reasons are the foundation of any order passed by any judicial or quasi judicial authority, and an order of an authority acting in a quasi-judicial manner should be a reasoned order.

Doctrine last updated on 28 October 2026

Cite this page

Reasoned Orders, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/reasoned-orders

1In Decco Worldwide Post Harvest Holdings B.V. v Controller of Patents and Designs (2023) the Calcutta High Court held that “Reasons are the foundation of any order passed by any judicial or quasi judicial authority. The main objective of providing reasons in any order is to provide clarity to the reader and to understand how and why and how the matter has been proceeded and dealt with by the Authority” (para 11).

2In Decco the Court held that “In passing the impugned order the Controller has failed to explain why the subject patent application falls within the category of ‘agriculture’. In fact, no reasons have been given by the Controller as to why a method of treatment of plants to treat fungal diseases would fall within section 3(h) which covers traditional methods of agriculture.” (para 11) It held that “the finding that the subject invention falls within the definition of ‘agriculture’ does not deal with the submissions of the appellants” and that the numerous inventions relied on by the appellants “have been totally ignored in the impugned order” (para 11).

3In Dimminaco v Controller of Patents and Designs (2002) the Calcutta High Court held that “It appears that while giving his report, the said Examiner has to act in a quasi-judicial manner and it is well settled as a proposition of law that when an authority, acting in a quasi-judicial manner, passes an order which affects the right of the parties such order should be a reasoned order.” On the report before it the Court found that “the main finding of the said Examiner is that the claimed specification does not constitute an invention. The reason for such finding has not been given.” (p 260)

4In Yahoo v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2011) the Intellectual Property Appellate Board held that any finding which is not based on reason cannot be accepted and will be set aside. (para 16)

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cases on this page

Case page

Decco Worldwide Post Harvest Holdings B.V. v Controller of Patents and Designs (2023)

High Court of Calcutta·19 May 2023

Case page

Dimminaco AG v Controller of Patents and Designs (2002)

High Court of Calcutta·15 January 2002

Case page

Yahoo Inc v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2011)

Intellectual Property Appellate Board·8 December 2011

Case page

Agriboard International LLC v Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs (2022)

High Court of Delhi·31 March 2022

Case page

Agfa NV v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2023)

High Court of Delhi·2 June 2023

Case page

Ceres Intellectual Property Company Limited v Controller of Patents, Trade Marks and Designs (2022)

High Court of Bombay·6 October 2022

Case page

Huntington Alloys Corporation v Union of India (2026)

High Court of Bombay·7 April 2026

Case page

Array Biopharma Inc v Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs (2026)

High Court of Delhi·23 July 2026

See also

Doctrine page

Examination and the First Examination Report

How must a patent examiner raise objections to a patent application?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/reasoned-orders