Shared terminology does not make a document prior art, abstracts of cited documents cannot be combined, and without a higher degree of credible challenge the injunction was restored.
Summary
The appellants “filed the suit for permanent injunction restraining the respondents from infringing the patent of the appellant No.1” (para 2), “The subject patent i.e. Indian Patent No.211175 for invention titled ‘Flat Fold Personal Respiratory Protection Devices and process for preparing the same’ was granted in favour of the appellants w.e.f. 26.05.1999.” (para 3) They contended that “the respondents have recently started manufacturing a device identical to the device covered by the subject patent” (para 8), while the respondents contended that “three patents namely US Patent No.US 3,971,369 (D1), US Patent No.US 5,701,892 (D2) and International Publication No.WO 1996/28217 (D3) disclose major elements that are claimed by the appellants patent and are prior arts” (para 11). The learned Single Judge held “that the said patents disclose many essential features of the subject patent and also teach many elements claimed in the subject patent” (para 12), and “The ex-parte ad interim injunction dated 19.12.2013 has thus been vacated.” (para 14)
To resolve the controversy the Bench held that “we would need to examine whether the comparison done by the learned single judge of the elements of the claim of the appellants in the subject patent with the alleged prior art satisfies the test as laid down by the Supreme Court of India” (para 19). On D1 it held that “Merely because the term ’lines of demarcation’ has been used in both the patents does not ipso-facto imply that both signify the same concept” (para 29), of D2 that it “does not teach the elements of the subject patent and, thus, could not have, prima facie, been considered as a prior art” (para 37), and of D3 that it “does not have any bisecting fold or lines of demarcation” (para 41). Of “the priority application made by the appellants in the United States with regard to the subject patent itself” the Bench held that “Reliance placed thereon by the learned Single Judge to show prior art is clearly misplaced” (para 42), that the Single Judge “has erroneously combined the abstract of D1, D2 and D3” (para 43), and that “the burden on the respondents was not only to show that there is a challenge to the patent but they also had to show a higher degree of credible challenge, which, in our view, the respondents have failed to show” (para 45). “In view of the above, the appeal is allowed. The impugned order dated 30.05.2014 is set aside. The order dated 19.12.2013 is confirmed till disposal of the suit.” (para 48)
What the court decided
- The principles of patentability. Reproducing Bishwanath Prasad Radhey Shyam v Hindustan Metal Industries, (1979) 2 SCC 511 (para 20), the Bench held that “The principles governing patentability of an invention as laid down in BISHWANATH PRASAD RADHEY SHYAM (Supra) can thus be summarized as under:” “(i) it must be the inventor’s own discovery; (ii) should not be a mere verification of what was already known before the date of the patent; (iii) it is a manner of new manufacture and includes an improvement and an allied invention; (iv) must also be useful; (v) not only the art, process or manner of providing, preparing or making an article but also the article prepared or produced by the manufacture can be patented; (vi) should be more than a mere workshop improvement; (vii) the improvement or the combination must produce a new result, or a new article or a better or cheaper article than before; (viii) a combination of old, known integers may be so combined that by their working ... produce a new process or improved result; (ix) mere collection of more than one integer or things, not involving the exercise of any inventive faculty, would not qualify for the grant of a patent; (x) there must be novelty in the mode of application and the novelty must show invention; (xi) the new subject-matter must involve ‘invention’ over what is old; (xii) must involve something which is outside the probable capacity of a craftsman; (xiii) it must not be the obvious to a skilled worker, in the field concerned, (xiv) it must not be a natural suggestion of what was previously known; (xv) Prior public knowledge of the alleged invention would disqualify the grant of a patent and prior public knowledge can be by word of mouth or by publication through books or other media” (paras 20-21)
- Construing the specification. Recording that “The Supreme Court in BISHWANATH PRASAD RADHEY SHYAM (Supra) also held that the proper way to construe a specification is not to read the claims first and then see what the full description of the invention is, but first to read the description of the invention, so that the mind may be prepared for what is claimed by the invention, because the patentee cannot claim more than what he desires to patent. The claims must be so construed as to give an effective meaning to each of them. The specification and the claims must be looked at and construed together.” (para 22), the Bench returned to the rule in deciding the appeal: “As held by the Supreme Court in BISWANATH PRASAD RADHEY SHYAM (Supra), the proper way to construe a specification is not to read the claims first and then see what the full description of the invention is, but first to read the description of the invention, in order that the mind may be prepared for what it is, that the invention is to be claimed, for the patentee cannot claim more than he desires to patent.” (paras 22, 44)
- The lines of demarcation in D1. The Bench held that “Examination of the abstract as also the figure of D1 shows that it teaches a ‘pleated’ mask, which has pleats formed on a face because of the material on the face portion being folded backwards.” and that “In the subject patent, the lines of demarcation are weld lines formed on the mask. The subject patent claims a non-pleated mask. Merely because the term ’lines of demarcation’ has been used in both the patents does not ipso-facto imply that both signify the same concept.” (para 29)
- Terminology and the detailed description. The Bench held that “The learned Single Judge merely referred to the terminology of the patents without referring to the detailed description thereof and thus erred in holding that D1 is a prior art and teaches with regard to the lines of demarcation.” In D1, it held, “the lines of demarcation refer to imaginary lines on which the blank is to be folded whereas in the subject patent, the lines of demarcation are predetermined lines formed on the main body of the mask by weld lines to distinguish different portions.” and that “It is apparent from the examination of the description of the subject patent with the alleged prior art that the lines of demarcation of the subject patent are different from the lines of demarcation in D1.” (paras 30-31)
- The bisecting fold. The Bench held that “The difference is apparent in the terms of the configuration and the functionality of the lines of demarcation. The respective purpose of the lines of demarcation is also different.” (para 32) and that “The bisecting fold, in combination with the lines of demarcation, provides a rigid, off the face configuration of the mask to ensure conformity to the face of the wearer and to provide a facial seal thereby avoiding any outside air from entering the mask when worn. D1 does not have any bisecting fold. Various other distinguishing features also exist between the subject patent and D1.” (paras 32-33)
- D2 as prior art. The Bench held that “Perusal of the abstract of D2 alongwith its figure shows that the mask of D2 does not have any lines of demarcation.” and that “Mask of D2 is not a monolithic structure and is made by joining two symmetrical sides. A comparison of D2 with the subject patent shows that D2 does not teach the elements of the subject patent and, thus, could not have, prima facie, been considered as a prior art.” (para 37)
- D3 as prior art. The Bench held that “A comparison of D3 with the subject patent shows that mask of D3 is not a monolithic structure and is formed by joining a flat first member and a flat second member to a central portion.” and that the mask of D3 “does not have any bisecting fold or lines of demarcation. The process of the subject patent is different in terms of the essential steps towards creating lines of demarcation and bisecting folds of the subject patent.” (para 41)
- The appellants’ own priority application. The Bench held that “US Patent No. US 6,394,090, granted on 28.05.2002, referred to in the impugned order is the priority application made by the appellants in the United States with regard to the subject patent itself. Reliance placed thereon by the learned Single Judge to show prior art is clearly misplaced.” (para 42)
- Combining the abstracts. The Bench held that “The learned Single Judge has erroneously combined the abstract of D1, D2 and D3 to arrive at a conclusion that the three combined teach the elements of the subject patent. By reading the alleged prior art documents relied upon by the Respondents, a person ordinarily skilled in the art would not be able to reach to the solution provided by the subject patent without use of inventive ingenuity.” (para 43)
- A higher degree of credible challenge. The Bench held that “The alleged prior arts relied upon by the respondents had been considered by the US Patent ... prior to the grant of the patent. The experts in the field i.e. the officials of the US Patent Office as also the officials of the Indian Patent Office have, not held that the three cited prior arts teach the elements of the subject patent or that there is obviousness of the elements to a person skilled in trade. In this view of the matter, the burden on the respondents was not only to show that there is a challenge to the patent but they also had to show a higher degree of credible challenge, which, in our view, the respondents have failed to show.” (para 45)
- Prima facie case and convenience. The Bench held that “the appellants have been able to show a strong prima facie case in their favour.”, recording that “Reliance is also placed on the catalogue available on the website of the respondent No.1 which refers to the infringing product as ‘New’.” (para 46) and that “the balance of convenience also lies in favour of the appellants and against the respondents.” (paras 46-47)
- Disposition. “In view of the above, the appeal is allowed. The impugned order dated 30.05.2014 is set aside. The order dated 19.12.2013 is confirmed till disposal of the suit.” (para 48) “IA No.20605/2013 (Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 CPC) is allowed and IA No.1276/2014 (under Order XXXIX Rule 4 CPC) is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.” (paras 48-49)
Subsequent treatment
Followed — in Avery Dennison v Controller of Patents and Designs (2022), where the Delhi High Court (Prathiba M. Singh J, 4 November 2022) held that “the examiner in the patent office or the Court adjudicating the issue would need to identify the elements in the prior art and compare the same with the claims in question from the point of view of a person skilled in the art, as was done by the ld. Division Bench of this Court in 3M Innovative Properties Ltd” (Avery Dennison, para 18).
Followed — in Nocil v Finorchem (2026), where the Calcutta High Court (Ravi Krishan Kapur J, 7 October 2026) held, citing this judgment with Mold Tek Packaging, that “the factum of grant of a patent though weighs in favour of the petitioner, it is open for a respondent to raise a sustainable or credible challenge either of invalidity or non-infringment” (Nocil, para 11).