Axcess Limited v Controller of Patents and Designs (2024)
High Court of Delhi·Saurabh Banerjee J·Single Judge·Decided 13 September 2024
Claims amended within the scope of the originally filed claims and supported by the specification are permissible under Section 59(1); the refusal is set aside and remanded.
Axcess Limited v Controller of Patents and Designs, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/axcess
Summary
“The appellant herein filed an Indian Patent Application No. 2427/DELNP/2011 titled “BILE ACIDS AND BIGUANIDES AS PROTEASE INHIBITORS FOR PRESERVING THE INTEGRITY OF PEPTIDES IN THE GUT”” (para 1), which “has been refused by the Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs” (para 2) “under Section 15 of the Patent Act, 1970” (para 2) in view of “59(1), 3(d) and 3(e) of the Act” (para 2). It was the appellant’s case that “the amended claims fall within the scope of the specifications and the claims originally filed, and the respondent’s conclusion regarding Section 59(1) of the Act is contrary to the facts on record” (para 5), and the respondent’s case that “the proposed amendments” “submitted post-hearing are beyond the scope of the original claims and the complete specification” (para 6).
The Court framed “the moot issue before this Court for analysing what the Controller has held qua Section 59(1) of the Act in the impugned order, is whether the appellant has deviated from the initial scope” (para 7). Applying the parameters of a coordinate bench, it held that “the amended claims in the latest complete specification filed by the appellant” “are well within the scope of the original PCT claims” (para 11) and “permissible and can be allowed” (para 12), so that “the rejection by the Controller under Section 59(1) of the Act by way of the impugned order cannot sustain and has to be reversed” (para 13). Since “the newly amended claims to the complete specifications of the appellant as they stand now have not been considered by the Controller at all” (para 13), the “impugned order” was “set aside and the matter is remanded back to the respondent for de novo consideration” (para 14).
What the court decided
-
Permissible limits of amendment. In Regents of the University of California v Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trademarks (2024) a coordinate bench, as the Court recorded, held that “amendments to the original application can be made only by way of” “Disclaimer”, “Correction” or “Explanation”, that the “Amendment should serve the purpose of incorporation of actual facts”, that the “Effect of the amendment should not allow matter not in substance, disclosed originally or shown in the specification”, and that the “Amended claim of the specification should fall within the scope of the original claim of the specification.” (para 10)
-
Amended claims within original scope. Applying those parameters, the Court held that “the amended claims in the latest complete specification filed by the appellant” “are well within the scope of the original PCT claims”, the “detailed description” supporting “the same amendment concerning the composition as a product.” (para 11)
-
Rejection under Section 59(1) reversed. The Court held that “the amended claims to the complete specifications sought by the appellant and as they stand now are permissible and can be allowed” (para 12), so that “the rejection by the Controller under Section 59(1) of the Act by way of the impugned order cannot sustain and has to be reversed.” (para 13)
-
Remand for de novo consideration. The Court held that “the newly amended claims to the complete specifications of the appellant as they stand now have not been considered by the Controller at all” (para 13), so that “the present appeal has to be remanded back to the Controller” and the “impugned order” “is set aside and the matter is remanded back to the respondent for de novo consideration.” (para 14)
Subsequent treatment
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 6 November 2026.
Provisions and topics
Cited in
Matter Not in Substance Disclosed
Case page · Page updated 6 November 2026
www.aop.onl/axcess