Natera Inc v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2025)
High Court of Delhi·9 October 2025
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
What did the Tek Chand and Ayyangar Committees find about the working of Indian patents?
The Tek Chand and Ayyangar Committees found a vast majority of Indian patents held by foreigners and not worked in India, and Ayyangar recommended the retention of the patent system.
Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026
The Tek Chand and Ayyangar Committees, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/ayyangar-report
1In 1948 the Government appointed a Patents Enquiry Committee under the chairmanship of Dr Bakshi Tek Chand, a retired judge of the Lahore High Court to review the working of the Indian Patent and Designs Act 1911 and to see whether the Indian patent system was in line with national interests. The final report of the Committee was submitted in 1950. Based on the recommendations of the Committee and largely modelled on the Patents Act 1949 of United Kingdom, the Patents Bill was introduced in the Lok Sabha on 7 December 1953. The bill lapsed with the dissolution of the first Lok Sabha.
2A fresh attempt was made by the government in 1957 when another committee was appointed under the chairmanship of Justice N Rajagopala Ayyangar to study and recommend changes to the patent law in India. (Justice N Rajagopala Ayyangar, ‘Report on the Revision of the Patent Laws’, September 1959.) Both the Tek Chand Committee and the Ayyangar Committee found that a vast majority of Indian patents were held by foreigners and most of them were not worked in India. The Ayyangar Committee recommended the retention of the patent system despite its shortcomings. The recommendations of the Ayyangar Committee, particularly the recommendations on patents for food, medicine or drug along with few other changes were introduced as the Patents Bill 1965 on 21 September 1965. A Joint Parliamentary Committee studied the Bill and submitted its report along with certain amendments to the Lok Sabha on 1 November 1966. Though the amended Bill was moved in the Lok Sabha on 5 December 1966, it lapsed with the dissolution of the third Lok Sabha on 3 March 1967. The Patents Bill was again introduced in 1967 with certain amendments. This time around, both the Houses of the Parliament passed the Bill and it received the Presidential assent on 19 September 1970. The Patent Rules was published in November 1971. The Act and the Rules came into force on 20 April 1972. (Certain excepted provisions of the Act, ie, ss 12(2), 13(2), 28, 68 and 125 to 132 came into force on 1 April 1978.)
3The Ayyangar Committee report has been cited in many cases to understand the history of the Act and the amendments made to it. In Natera v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2025) and Sequenom v Controller of Patents (2025) the Delhi High Court held that “even the Ayyangar Committee Report recorded that medicinal, surgical, curative, prophylactic and other treatment of man or processes for the treatment of plants or animals are considered as non-patentable universally” (para 66), and that “Following the above recommendations, Section 3(i) was added for the first time in the Act” (para 67). In EMD Millipore v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2025) the Court observed on the findings of the Ayyangar Committee that “a need was felt by the Committee to add this as a specific exclusion under the 1911 Act, which required methods of manufacture for patentable inventions, as there was no provision covering the said exclusions” (para 52), and set out the provision as first enacted, “Section 3(i) - any process for the medicinal, surgical, curative, prophylactic or other treatment of human beings or any process for a similar treatment of animals or plants to render them free of disease or to increase their economic value or that of their products” (para 53). The exclusion is treated in Methods of Medical Treatment.
4In Immunas Pharma v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2024) the Madras High Court held that “The Patents Act was enacted pursuant to a report of the Iyyangar Committee. In the said report, at paragraph 328 thereof, the Committee was of the view that discoveries are universally not patentable”, and that “Given that the Patents Act was intended to foster inventiveness and not to reward discovery of things that already exist, the basis for the exclusion is clearly discernible” (para 11). The same passage appears in Genmab v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2024) (para 13). The exclusion is treated in Discovery Is Not Invention.
5In Communication Components Antenna v Mobi Antenna Technologies (Shenzhen) Co (2022) the Delhi High Court, holding that the grounds of insufficiency of disclosure had to be decided on the existing pleadings and the evidence led, thought it “apposite to rely upon the extracts from the ‘Report on the Revisions of Patent Law’ by Justice Shri. N. Rajagopala Iyengar” and set out its paras 575 and 576. The Report there drew attention to “a slight change which I have introduced in ground (h) relating to insufficiency of description of a complete specification”, the addition of the words that “the description of the method or the instructions for the working of the invention as contained in the complete specification are not by themselves sufficient to enable a person in India possessing average skill in, and average knowledge of, the art to which the invention relates, to work the invention.” Of that addition it said, “These words no doubt merely summarise the effect of the decisions in the U.K. as regards the sufficiency of the instruction which a complete specification ought to contain, but I believe that their inclusion in the grounds would serve to emphasise the purpose in law of a specification.” Its reason was that although “the decisions on sufficiency of description relate the required quantum of instruction to the state of the art in the country to whose technicians the specification is addressed, I consider that the iteration of this requirement would induce foreign applications for patents to pay heed to this feature and also focus the attention of the courts to have regard to the state of the art in this country in judging of the sufficiency of description.” (para 13)
High Court of Delhi·9 October 2025
High Court of Delhi·9 October 2025
High Court of Madras·6 March 2024
High Court of Madras·6 March 2024
High Court of Delhi·4 February 2022
What must a complete specification disclose to be sufficient in India?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/ayyangar-report