Dr Aloys Wobben v Yogesh Mehra (2014)
Supreme Court of India
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
High Court of Bombay·Somasekhar Sundaresan J·Single Judge·Decided 2 November 2026
A defendant pleading invalidity by counter-claim without a separate revocation petition raises no risk of parallel proceedings; the revocation issue is framed on the pleadings.
Bharat Bhogilal Patel v Raymond Limited, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/bharat-bhogilal
In a commercial patent infringement suit, the defendant pointed to its “Counter Claim” and submitted that an issue be framed — “Whether the Defendant proves that the Plaintiff’s Patent Nos. 188787 and 189027 are invalid and liable to be revoked under provisions of Section 64 of the Patents Act, 1970” (para 2). The plaintiff, relying on the Supreme Court in Aloys Wobben v Yogesh Mehra (2014), submitted that “it is not open to the Defendant to sustain the Counter Claim, since it is in the nature of a revocation, the Defendant having chosen not to file a Revocation Petition” (para 3).
The Court held that “at this stage, the issues are being framed in terms of the pleadings made by the parties, and as a matter of fact, no Revocation Petition has been filed by the Defendant” (para 4); that “The objective behind Section 64(1) of the Patents Act, 1970, and the decision cited above, prima facie, is aimed at ensuring that parallel proceedings with conflicting outcomes are avoided” (para 4); and that, there being “no Revocation Petition in the instant case”, “the objection to the amendment does not appeal to me” (para 4).
Issues framed on the pleadings. The Court held that “at this stage, the issues are being framed in terms of the pleadings made by the parties, and as a matter of fact, no Revocation Petition has been filed by the Defendant.” (para 4)
No parallel proceedings. The Court held that “The objective behind Section 64(1) of the Patents Act, 1970, and the decision cited above, prima facie, is aimed at ensuring that parallel proceedings with conflicting outcomes are avoided”, and that, there being “no Revocation Petition in the instant case, and the submissions on the merits for revocation” “taken up only in the Counter Claim”, “the objection to the amendment does not appeal to me.” (para 4)
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 6 November 2026.
Case page · Page updated 13 November 2026
www.aop.onl/bharat-bhogilal