Doctrine page

Costs and Actual Costs

Can a successful patentee in India recover complete actual costs of the suit?

Costs are at the discretion of the court under section 35 CPC, and complete actual costs follow where a defendant's conduct has been far from bonafide.

Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026

Cite this page

Costs and Actual Costs, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/costs

1Generally costs are paid by the unsuccessful party to the party who succeeds in the suit. The award of costs shall be at the discretion of the court. The court also has the power to award compensatory costs in respect of false and vexatious claims and defences. If a party abandons its motion for interlocutory relief, the defendant will be entitled to costs. (See Kickers International SA v Paul Kettle Agencies Ltd [1990] FSR 436 (registered design case).)

2Costs may also be awarded in respect of delay. Thus, where a party prolongs the case at the interim stage by canvassing lengthy arguments on the merits of the case which are not entirely necessary, the court may award costs at the interim stage. (See Apple Corps Ltd v Apple Computer Inc (1992) RPC 70 (trademark case).) Costs may cover the expenses incurred in conducting the suit, including the counsel’s fees. If a certificate of validity has been granted in an earlier action, it must be specifically pleaded by the party so as to be entitled for costs. (See Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v RF Chisholm & Co (1896) 13 RPC 488.)

3In Communication Components Antenna v Rosenberger Hochfrequenztechnik KG (2026) the Delhi High Court, finding after trial that “the conduct of the Defendants has been far from bonafide” (para 352), held that “Under these circumstances, the Plaintiff is entitled to complete actual costs in this matter.” (para 353) Of a defence that puts every ground it can reach to the patent the Court said that “The Dartboard approach of Defendants in patent litigation ought to be dealt with imposition of heavy costs.” (para 209)

4In Eisai Co v Satish Reddy (2019) the Delhi High Court directed that “Both the parties are directed to submit the actual cost incurred by them” and that “The parties are also directed to submit their estimate of future cost before the commencement of trial so that the parties shall have notice of actual cost that the other side estimate would be incurring in the course of litigation and the parties have an opportunity to take appropriate decision as to manner in which to conduct the litigation.” (para 55) The Court added that “Greater transparency about cost will promote access to justice.” (para 55)

Provisions and topics

Provisions

Cases on this page

Case page

Communication Components Antenna Inc v Rosenberger Hochfrequenztechnik GmbH & Co. KG (2026)

High Court of Delhi·30 March 2026

Case page

Eisai Co Ltd v Satish Reddy (2019)

High Court of Delhi·6 May 2019

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/costs