F Hoffmann-La Roche v Cipla (2012)
High Court of Delhi·7 September 2012
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
Does section 8 require Form 3 disclosure of foreign applications filed after the Indian application?
Section 8(1) covers within its sweep not merely the applications which are being prosecuted at the time of filing of patent, but also the other applications which are filed subsequently.
Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026
Foreign Filing Statement — Form 3, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/form-3
1In cases where the applicant for a patent under the Patents Act is prosecuting either alone or jointly with any other person an application for a patent in any country outside India in respect of the same or substantially the same invention, or where to his knowledge such an application is being prosecuted by some person through whom he claims or by some person deriving title from him, he shall file, along with his application, or within six months from the date of filing, a statement and an undertaking as prescribed in Form 3. (Patents Act 1970, s 8(1); Patents Rules 2003, r 12(1A).) If there is no such foreign application, the applicant shall file a statement to that effect.
2The statement shall set out the detailed particulars of such application including the name of the country, application number and status of such application. The undertaking given by the applicant shall state that, up to the date of the grant of his complete specification filed in India, the applicant would keep the Controller informed in writing, from time to time, the detailed particulars as required under cl (a) of s 8(1) of the Patents Act in respect of every other application relating to the same or substantially the same invention, if any, filed in any country outside India subsequently to the filing of the statement referred to in the aforesaid clause, within six months of such filing.
3At any time after an application for patent is filed in India and till the grant of patent or refusal to grant of patent is made, the Controller may also require the applicant to furnish details as may be prescribed relating to the processing of the application in a country outside India, and the applicant shall furnish information available to him to the Controller within six months from the date of receipt of the communication requiring such furnishing of information. (Patents Act 1970, s 8(2); Patents Rules 2003, r 12(2).) In case of delay in furnishing the details beyond six months, the applicant may seek for further extension of time by filing a petition under r 138.
4In F Hoffmann-La Roche v Cipla (2012) the Delhi High Court held that “Section 8(1) covers within its sweep not merely the applications which are being prosecuted at the time of filing of patent, but also the other applications which are filed subsequently during the time when the prosecution before the Indian Patents Office is underway.” (para 137) It held that “what is the requirement of law u/s 8 is the disclosure in respect of same or substantially the same invention which may subsume within its ambit the inventions which are substantially the same but may have slight difference here and there” (para 151).
5In Nokia Technologies v Guangdong Oppo Mobile Telecommunications (2023), an infringement suit, the Delhi High Court directed: “In view of the various decisions of Courts in Europe placed on record by the Defendant, let the Plaintiff place on record an updated Form-3 in respect of all the seven patents asserted in the present suits within a period of two weeks.” (para 17)
High Court of Delhi·29 November 2023
Does failure to disclose foreign applications under section 8 always lead to revocation?
Does an Indian resident need the Controller's permission before filing a patent application abroad?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/form-3