Garware-Wall Ropes Ltd v Techfab India Ltd (2008)
High Court of Gujarat·M.S. Shah & K.A. Puj JJ·Division Bench·Decided 25 April 2008·AIR 2008 (NOC) 2415 (Guj)
An appeal against refusal of an interim injunction on a gabion patent was dismissed: the prior art raised a serious controversy over validity and damages sufficed.
Garware-Wall Ropes Ltd v Techfab India Ltd, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/garware-techfab
Summary
“The appellant-original plaintiff has filed this appeal challenging the interlocutory order dated 13.07.2006 passed by the Learned Single Judge of this Court below injunction application Exh. 5 in Civil Suit No. 04 of 2005 whereby the injunction as prayed for was refused.” (para 1) The appellant held a patent on a pre-fabricated collapsible gabion product made from ropes, and the respondents, “challenged the validity of the patented” invention “and sought that such patent granted in favour of the appellant be revoked, through the written statement”. (para 7)
The Division Bench held that the material on record “prima facie persuaded us to take the view that the learned Single Judge has not committed any error either in law or on facts in refusing to grant interim relief as prayed for by the appellants-plaintiffs” (para 40), that “There is a serious controversy raised in the counter claim regarding the validity of the patent claimed by and granted in favour of the plaintiff on several grounds. Therefore, there is no prima facie case for grant of an interim relief as prayed for” (para 51), and accordingly “we dismiss this appeal and confirm the interlocutory order of the learned Single Judge”. (para 63)
What the court decided
-
Grant is no proof of validity. “The defendant’s contention that grant of patent is not a prima facie proof of validity certainly merits consideration. Section 13(4) of the Act states that examination and investigation required under Section 12 and this section shall not be deemed in any way to warrant the validity of any patent”; and “it is humanly impossible for any examiner to check for prior art in all the databases not only of patents granted or pending in all languages all over the world, but also all other documents or publications including prior knowledge”. (para 54)
-
New product versus improvement. “Patent only for improvement made on the existing prior art, could have been granted, if the features added to the existing gabion involved technical advance as compared to the existing knowledge that made the invention not obvious to the persons skilled in the art. Since claim made was not for an improvement made but of inventing a new product, the patent may be revoked on the ground of suppression or on the ground that claim made is not an invention within the meaning of Section 2(1)(j) of the Act.” (para 51)
-
Prior art known before the application. “It is now an undisputed position that Gabion products having most of the features (if not all) as claimed by the plaintiff in the patent application were known and used since a number of years prior to the date of application.” (para 51)
-
Improvement not examined. “the Controller of Patent had no occasion to consider whether the improvement made in such a technological advance which would merit grant of patent and secondly whether to limit the grant of patent only to such improvements or grant patent as an invention of a new product”, so “This aspect will be considered for the first time in the revocation proceedings.” (para 52)
-
Combination as novelty. “Even if a combination of features, independently found to exist in different gabion products, can be claimed to be novelty as contended by the plaintiff, such a claim should have been made by the plaintiff after discovering the existing prior art. The issue to be tried in revocation petition would be, which prior art contained which features and whether plaintiff’s product contains features which involve technological advance over prior art which is non-obvious to the person in the same field of art.” (para 53)
-
Serious controversy, no prima facie case. “There is a serious controversy raised in the counter claim regarding the validity of the patent claimed by and granted in favour of the plaintiff on several grounds. Therefore, there is no prima facie case for grant of an interim relief as prayed for.” (para 51)
-
Damages an adequate remedy. “The Learned Single Judge has adequately protected the interest of the plaintiff by directing the defendant to maintain account and directing the defendant to secure their claim for damages. The plaintiff has not shown how and why payment of compensation is not an adequate remedy.” (para 50)
-
Procedure. Disposition. “we find ourselves in agreement with the interlocutory order passed by the learned Single Judge. Subject to the above direction, we dismiss this appeal and confirm the interlocutory order of the learned Single Judge with a clarification that the suit and the counter claim shall be decided in accordance with law, without being influenced by any observation in this order.” (para 63)
Subsequent treatment
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 2 November 2026.
Provisions and topics
Cited in
The Workshop Improvement Standard
The Definition of Inventive Step
Case page · Page updated 6 November 2026
www.aop.onl/garware-techfab