F Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd v Cipla Ltd (2009)
High Court of Delhi
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
High Court of Delhi·Manmohan Singh J·Single Judge·Decided 27 January 2010·2010 (43) PTC 630 (Del); 2010 SCC OnLine Del 308
Interim injunction on a mirror-coating patent was refused: the defendants' prior art raised a credible challenge to validity, and the balance of convenience favoured them.
The plaintiff’s application sought “an ad-interim injunction restraining the defendants” from infringing its patent, the invention being “related to a mirror without a copper layer with the processes including sensitization, activation, silvering and layering”, which “uses essential ingredients including treatment with tin and/ or palladium chloride”. (paras 1, 69)
The Court held that “this court has to examine the challenge made to the patent as to whether there is any serious, triable dispute which is made out and the same renders the patent vulnerable to challenge or not” (para 66), and found that “the defendants have raised substantial, tenable and credible challenge to the patent which raises a triable dispute, therefore, the plaintiff has failed to make out a prima facie case for the grant of ad interim injunction” (para 87). The application was “disposed of” with directions expediting the suit and requiring the defendants to keep accounts. (para 92)
Revocation grounds as a defence. “the grounds of challenge of the patent which are available to the defendant in revocation of the patent are also available to the defendant by way of challenging the validity of the same in an infringement suit.” (para 64)
Grant no bar to challenge. Adopting the Division Bench in F Hoffmann-La Roche v Cipla (2009), “the grant of such patent to the plaintiffs will not ipso facto entitle them to an interim injunction if the defendant is able to satisfy the court that there is question to be tried as to the validity of the patent”, the defendant there having “raised a credible challenge to the validity of the patent by raising the serious triable and substantial question that renders it vulnerable to challenge.” (para 65)
The test applied. “this court has to examine the challenge made to the patent as to whether there is any serious, triable dispute which is made out and the same renders the patent vulnerable to challenge or not.” (para 66)
The trinity of patentability. “novelty, inventive step and industrial application are the three trinity tests of patentability and the same are to be satisfied independently of each other although it is separate issue that they may be interdependent upon each other”. (para 67)
Prior art renders the patent vulnerable. “the defendants have cited several prior arts which relates to similar processes as mentioned above which, prima facie in the opinion of this court, show that the patent of the plaintiff is vulnerable to challenge” (para 70); “The challenge to the patent made by the defendants is not unfounded and rather it raises a serious credible challenge to the patent”. (paras 70–71)
No prima facie case. “the defendants have raised substantial, tenable and credible challenge to the patent which raises a triable dispute, therefore, the plaintiff has failed to make out a prima facie case for the grant of ad interim injunction. Considerable doubt has been raised by this court about the working of the patent in commercial sense”. (para 87)
Balance of convenience. “it would be more inconvenient at this juncture to restrain the defendants from manufacturing the mirrors given the fact that there is substantial credible challenge raised to the patent, on the contrary, the plaintiff would be less inconvenienced at this stage if the injunction is not granted. The irreparable damage consequently will be caused to the defendants if there is an injunction against them.” (para 89)
Procedure. Disposition. “The suit proceedings shall be expedited”; “The defendants are directed to maintain the accounts and file it on monthly basis in this Court in respect of the sales arising without copper layer mirrors”; and “The defendants shall file an undertaking by way of an affidavit within two weeks from today that in case the suit of the plaintiff is decreed after trial, the defendants shall pay the profits and damages on their sale of impugned product without copper layer to the plaintiff.” (para 92)
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 2 November 2026.
Case page · Page updated 14 November 2026
www.aop.onl/glaverbel