Case page

Andreas Gutzeit v Controller General of Patents Designs and Trademark (2025)

High Court of Calcutta·Ravi Krishan Kapur J·Single Judge·Decided 15 May 2025

Good law Appeal IPDPTA 7 of 2024 allowed: the refusal of application no. 201637000002 under section 59 set aside and the matter remanded to the Controller for decision afresh within eight weeks after a hearing, the merits left open. No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 20 October 2026.

A refusal under section 59 that treated a method-to-system amendment as broadening without examining the original specification was unreasoned: order set aside, application remanded for fresh decision.

Cite this page

Andreas Gutzeit v Controller General of Patents Designs and Trademark, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/gutzeit

Judgment PDF

Summary

“This is an appeal directed against an order dated 1st April, 2024 rejecting an application for patent titled ‘Blood Flow Control System and Method for In-vivo Imaging and Other Application’ being application no. 201637000002 filed under section 15 of the Patents Act, 1970.” (para 1) “The present invention relates to blood flow control systems, devices and methods, in particular to an imaging system for the human body, such as x-ray and related tomographic imaging systems.” (para 3) “The claim was amended and reply to the FER was duly filed. By the impugned order, the application for patent has been rejected solely on the ground of non-compliance with section 59 of the Act.” (para 6) For the respondent it was contended that “The appellant by way of amendment was seeking to change the original claim i.e. method claim to a system claim. Such change is expressly prohibited under section 59 of the Act.” (para 8)

The Court held that “Whether system to method or product to process, one has to examine the original specification and ascertain the intrinsic worth of the invention vis-a-vis the proposed amendment.” (para 19) It found that “The conclusion that the methods claims had changed to a system claims and hence were beyond the scope of the original claims is unsubstantiated and bereft of any reasoning.” (para 20) “In view of the above, the impugned order is unsustainable and is set aside. The matter is remanded to the Controller to be decided afresh in accordance with law within a period of eight weeks from the date of communication of this order and after granting an opportunity of hearing to the appellant.” (para 21) “To the above extent, IPDPTA 7 of 2024 stands allowed.” (para 22)

What the court decided

  1. The limits of amendment. “As a general rule, patent applications, complete specification or any other document, can be amended only if it is in the form of a disclaimer, correction or explanation. Any addition or amendment beyond the scope of the original claim ought to be supported by a disclaimer. The crucial question being whether any subject matter relevant to the invention has been added whether by deletion or addition. Thus, great care has to be taken when formulating and seeking amendments, in view of the danger that the patent may be invalidated by adding matter or by a widening amendment.” (para 17)
  2. The category of the claim. “There can be no straight jacket formula in such cases. Nor can the label or nomenclature be treated as the sole indicator. Whether system to method or product to process, one has to examine the original specification and ascertain the intrinsic worth of the invention vis-a-vis the proposed amendment. The question of addition or deletion has to be examined in this background.” (para 19)
  3. What the Controller did not examine. “In passing the impugned order, the Assistant Controller though aware of the fact that the original claim mentioned contrast dye failed to discuss whether the same fell within the scope of the original specification or not. The impugned order does not decide whether the invention is comprehended within the matter disclosed or not.” “How any of the features or elements of the proposed amendments broaden the scope of the original claim has not even been adjudicated upon nor elaborated upon in the impugned order. That is a serious infirmity in the impugned order.” (para 19)
  4. The test of added matter. After setting out Jacob J’s test in Richardson-Vick Inc’s Patent “whether a skilled man would, upon looking at the amended specification, learn anything about the invention which he could not learn from the unamended specification”, the Court held: “A third party must be able to look at an application and be able to draw a conclusion with respect to the subject matter that is available for supporting a claimed monopoly. A subject matter if added subsequently, the patentee could obtain a different monopoly to that which the application originally justified. The impugned order simply fails to deal with this aspect of the matter.” (para 20)
  5. An unreasoned refusal. “The conclusion that the methods claims had changed to a system claims and hence were beyond the scope of the original claims is unsubstantiated and bereft of any reasoning. There are no reasons in concluding as to how the proposed amendments broadened, expanded or widened the claims.” (para 20)
  6. Remand. “In view of the above, the impugned order is unsustainable and is set aside. The matter is remanded to the Controller to be decided afresh in accordance with law within a period of eight weeks from the date of communication of this order and after granting an opportunity of hearing to the appellant.” “To the above extent, IPDPTA 7 of 2024 stands allowed.” (paras 21–22)

What the court did not decide

“It is made clear that there has been no adjudication on the merits of the claim and all points are left open.” (para 21)

Subsequent treatment

No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 20 October 2026.

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cases this judgment relies on

Cited in

Case page · Page updated 17 November 2026

www.aop.onl/gutzeit