InterDigital Technology Corporation v Xiaomi Corporation (2021)
High Court of Delhi·C. Hari Shankar J·Single Judge·Decided 3 May 2021
A foreign anti-suit injunction barring a patentee from suing on Indian patents in the only competent court was oppressive; its enforcement was injuncted and any fine indemnified.
InterDigital Technology Corporation v Xiaomi Corporation, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/interdigital-xiaomi-2021
Summary
The suit “alleges infringement, by the defendants, of certain Standard Essential Patents (SEPs), held by the plaintiff and registered in their name.” (para 6) “Prior to the plaintiffs approaching this Court by way of the present suit on 29th July, 2020, the defendants had filed an SEP royalty rate-setting suit” “before the Wuhan Court” “on 9th June, 2020” (para 8). “On the very same day” as summons issued here, “the defendants filed an anti-suit injunction application before the Wuhan Court for a restraint, against the plaintiffs, from prosecuting the present suit before this Court.” (para 9) By order dated 23rd September, 2020 the Wuhan Court restrained the plaintiffs, on pain of “a fine of RMB 1 million yuan per day” (para 10). “By the present application, the plaintiffs seek an injunction, against the defendants, from enforcing, against them, the aforesaid directions issued by the Wuhan Court.” (para 11)
The Court held that “Perceived infringement of Indian patents can, indisputably, be challenged only in India, patent rights being territorial in nature” (para 100), and that “a foreign court has restrained the plaintiff from prosecuting a proceeding which is maintainable before this Court, and could not be maintained before any other Court.” (para 105.2) The Wuhan proceedings “were, in that regard, prima facie oppressive in nature” (para 106), and the defendants’ concealment “amounts to fraud on the Court as well as material concealment from the plaintiffs.” (para 114) “The ad interim injunction granted by this Court on 9th October, 2020 is made absolute” and “The defendant shall remain restrained, during the pendency of the present suit, from enforcing, against the plaintiffs, the order dated 23rd September, 2020, passed by the Wuhan Court.” (para 119)
What the court decided
- Three forms of injunction. “Injunctions, of legal proceedings in foreign climes, may, plainly, take one of the three forms. There are anti-suit injunctions, in which the Court injuncts the party from proceeding with the main suit, pending before the foreign Court; ‘anti-anti-suit injunctions’”, “where the Court injuncts the party from proceeding with the anti-suit injunction application filed before the foreign Court to injunct the ’local’ proceedings, and ‘anti-enforcement injunctions’, where the Court injuncts one of the parties before it from enforcing, against the other, a decree or order passed by a foreign Court.” (para 76) “Referring to ‘anti-enforcement injunctions’ as ‘anti-anti-suit injunctions’ would, in my view, be a misnomer.” (paras 76, 80)
- The two touchstones. “In view thereof, in my opinion, the present application of the plaintiffs has to be examined on two touchstones (or ‘issues’), viz. (i) whether the plaintiffs are entitled to seek a restraint against execution or enforcement, by the defendants, of the order dated 23rd September, 2020, passed by the Wuhan Court, and (ii) whether a case for injuncting the defendants from prosecuting the anti-suit injunction application, filed by them before the Wuhan Court, in which the order dated 23rd September, 2020 came to be passed, could be said to have existed, had the plaintiffs approached this Court when the application was still pending.” (para 83)
- Exceptionality. “I cannot, therefore, subscribe to the view, expressed by the Singapore Court of Appeal, that a greater degree of circumspection is required when dealing with a prayer for anti-enforcement injunction, as compared to a prayer for anti-suit injunction.” “Plainly said, at the end of the day, the interests of justice must prevail. If rendering of justice, in a given case, requires an anti-enforcement injunction to be issued, the Court should not hold back its hands, on some perceived notion of lack of ’exceptionality’ in the case.” (para 84)
- The general principles. “I find myself, however, in agreement with the following general principles relating to anti-suit and anti-enforcement injunctions, emerging from ‘foreign’ jurisprudence”: “An anti-suit injunction should be granted only in rare cases, and not for the mere asking.” “Interference with the right to pursue one’s legal remedies, before the forum which was competent to adjudicate thereon, amounts to ‘oppression’, especially where there is no other forum which the litigant could approach.” “A proceeding, or an order, which resulted in divesting the patent holder of the authority to exercise this fundamental right, was ex facie oppressive in nature.” “Where the proceeding or order, of which injunction was sought, was oppressive to the applicant seeking injunction, comity was of relatively little importance, as a factor telling against grant of such injunction.” “Comity, in any event, was a two-way street.” “There was no reason to treat anti-execution injunction applications as ’exceptional’”. “Some instances in which anti-enforcement injunction is would be justified are” “where the judgment, of the execution of which injunction was sought, was obtained too quickly or too secretly to enable the applicant” “to take pre-emptive remedial measures”, “where the order, of the execution of which injunction was sought, was obtained fraudulently”, and “where the applicant seeking anti-enforcement injunction had no means of knowing of the passing of the judgment or order against, until it was served on him.” (para 88)
- Justifiability of the foreign order. “I am acutely conscious of the fact that I am not sitting in appeal over the order, dated 23rd September, 2020, of the Wuhan Court. Nonetheless, one of the factors which has to be borne in mind by this Court, in deciding whether to restrain the defendants from enforcing, against the plaintiffs, the order of the Wuhan Court, is unquestionably the justifiability of such order.” “Where, however, the order passed by the Court of one sovereign country, without due justification, entrenches on the lawful invocation of remedies known to law, by a litigant in another sovereign country, the Court in the latter sovereign country is duty bound to protect such incursion on its jurisdiction, and on the fundamental right of its citizen to seek legal redress. No consideration of comity can militate against grant of relief in such a case.” (para 90)
- Considerations not recognised. “Findings (iv), (viii), (ix), (x) and (xi) are, with respect, not considerations relevant for grant of anti-suit injunction, either according to the anti-suit injunction law as it exists in this country, or, for that matter, the antisuit injunction law as it exists in any other jurisdiction.” “While reiterating that I am not sitting in appeal over the findings or observations of the Wuhan Court, I merely seek to observe that these factors are not recognised as factors for grant of anti-suit injunction, in any jurisdiction of which I am aware, or any legal authority to which the defendants have drawn my attention.” (paras 91–92)
- Notice of the anti-suit application. “Notice, in the main proceedings, quite obviously, does not amount to notice in every application filed therein. Nor can a litigant, who is not clairvoyant by nature, be expected to have knowledge of every application filed in the main proceeding, merely because he has been put on notice in that main proceeding.” (para 94.3) The plaintiffs’ failure to appear in the complaint “cannot be treated as relevant for the purposes of granting antisuit injunction, restraining the plaintiffs from prosecuting the present proceedings.” (paras 94.3–94.4)
- Scope of the two proceedings. “There is substance in the contention of Mr. Banerjee, therefore, that the issue of FRAND” (“fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory”) “royalty rates arises, in the present case, only as a part of the entire gamut of the controversy before this Court.” (para 98) “It is obvious, at a bare glance, that the issue of infringement, by the defendants, of the suit patents or, for that matter, of any of the patents of the plaintiffs, is not going to be addressed by the Wuhan Court”. “Unlike the Wuhan proceedings, this Court, at least foreseeably, is not required to enter into fixation of a global FRAND rate covering the entire portfolio of the plaintiff’s SEPs.” (paras 98–99)
- Territoriality and jurisdiction. “Perceived infringement of Indian patents can, indisputably, be challenged only in India, patent rights being territorial in nature and patents themselves being granted only by the concerned sovereign state.” “Rather, the Wuhan Court has, by its order, sought to exclude the jurisdiction of this Court to adjudicate on the lis brought before it by the plaintiff which this Court, and no other, is empowered to adjudicate” (para 100). “In other words, what has happened in the present case is that a foreign court has restrained the plaintiff from prosecuting a proceeding which is maintainable before this Court, and could not be maintained before any other Court.” (paras 100, 105.2)
- Overlap of issues. “Mere overlap of issues is not regarded, either by the law in this country or in any other jurisdiction, as sufficient to grant anti-suit injunction. It is only where the overlap results in the foreign proceedings being rendered ‘oppressive or vexatious’ that anti-suit injunction may be justified.” (para 102) “It need hardly be stated that every overlap of issues cannot justify an anti-suit injunction.” (paras 102–103)
- Conflicting orders. “To my mind, a step so extreme as an anti-suit injunction cannot be justified on a mere apprehension of the possibility of conflicting orders, were proceedings in both jurisdictions to be allowed to proceed.” “It would, therefore, be too simplistic to treat the mere apprehension of a possibility of two views, on one issue, resulting, as justifying a Court in one sovereign jurisdiction injuncting, in its tracks, proceedings in another.” (para 104)
- Oppression. “The proceedings arising out of the anti-suit injunction application filed by the defendants before the Wuhan Court were, in that regard, prima facie oppressive in nature” (para 106). “There being no other forum before which the plaintiffs could agitate their claim against infringement, it is totally unthinkable that a forum which has no jurisdiction in that regard could injunct the plaintiffs from agitating the issue before the only forum which has. Such injunction cannot be allowed to continue even for a single day.” “Damages are but poor solace, once the damage itself is done.” (paras 106–107)
- Microsoft v Motorola not followed. Of the finding of the Court of Appeal in Microsoft Corp. v Motorola Inc., the Court held: “With respect, this finding, in my view, is completely unacceptable, and I am constrained, therefore, to express my inability to concur therewith.” “The right to seek remedy against infringement of patents, validly held by the plaintiff, is a pre-eminent right, with the right to claim damages being residuary in nature, and not vice versa.” (para 109)
- The concluding view. “In my view, therefore, it is totally impermissible for a Court in one sovereign jurisdiction to injunct the party before it from pursuing its cause against infringement of its intellectual property before another sovereign jurisdiction, where such latter jurisdiction is the only forum competent to adjudicate the claim of infringement, save and except where continuation of the infringement proceedings are vexatious or oppressive to the proceedings pending before the former, injuncting, court.” (para 110) “The right of the citizen, in this country, to legal redressal to ventilate his legitimate rights, is hallowed, sacred, and fundamental.” (para 111) “This guarantee cannot be sacrificed at the altar of comity.” (paras 110–112)
- Concealment from the Court. “A transparent intent, to keep the plaintiffs, as well as this Court, in the dark, regarding the filing of the anti-suit injunction application, and the passing of the order, thereon, it is apparent.” “It amounts to fraud on the Court as well as material concealment from the plaintiffs. Even on this sole ground, I am convinced that the defendants deserve to be injuncted from enforcing, against the plaintiffs, the order dated 23rd September, 2020, of the Wuhan Court, passed in such circumstances.” (para 114)
- Indemnity for the fine. “Once it has been found that enforcement of the anti-suit injunction order of the Wuhan Court, by the defendant against the plaintiffs, deserves to be injuncted, it follows merely as a sequitur that the plaintiffs cannot be fastened with the ‘fine’ imposed by said order of the Wuhan Court.” “It is, quite obviously, not permissible for this Court to restrain the Wuhan Court from passing any order.” “This follows as a natural corollary to the restraint, of the execution of the Wuhan Court order against the plaintiffs, on plain principles of restitution.” (paras 116–117)
- The troika. “Applying the troika test of prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable loss, therefore, grant of anti-enforcement injunction, as sought by the plaintiffs, would be eminently justified.” (para 118)
- Disposition. “The ad interim injunction granted by this Court on 9th October, 2020 is made absolute”; “The defendant shall remain restrained, during the pendency of the present suit, from enforcing, against the plaintiffs, the order dated 23rd September, 2020, passed by the Wuhan Court.” On any order of the Wuhan Court “towards deposit of the fine of RMB 1 million per day”, “the defendants shall, within one week of passing of the said order”, “secure such amount of fine, imposed on the plaintiffs, by depositing, with the Registrar General of this Court, an equivalent amount”, and on the prayer for withdrawal of the Wuhan complaint, “no orders are being passed”. (para 119)
Subsequent treatment
Distinguished in InterDigital Patent Holdings v Shenzhen Transsion Holdings Co (2026), where the Court held that “this suit examines the trans border jurisdiction and anti-enforcement injunction, and does not talk about the validity, essentiality, therefore, this court believes that this decision is not relevant to rely on at this stage” (para 78).
Provisions and topics
Cited in
Case page · Page updated 22 November 2026
www.aop.onl/interdigital-xiaomi-2021