Opposition in the Indian Patent System
Can a patent be opposed both before and after grant in India, and by whom?
Opposition lies before the Patent Office both before grant under section 25(1), by any person, and after grant under section 25(2), by an interested person only.
Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026
Opposition in the Indian Patent System, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/opposition
1Opposition to the grant of a patent signifies the first instance at which a challenge can be made to the grant of a patent under the Act. The characteristic feature of opposition proceedings available under the patent laws of various countries is the fact that it can be initiated before the authority which grants the patent, ie, the Patent Office. Generally, opposition proceedings are regarded as administrative in nature as they happen within the Patent Office and not before a judicial authority. The opposition proceedings under the Act are unique, as they provide for opposition before the grant of a patent (pre-grant opposition) as well as for opposition after the grant (post-grant opposition).
2An opposition is instituted to challenge an application before its grant or to revoke a patent already granted on the grounds enumerated in s 25 of the Patents Act. The logic of opposition proceedings proceeds from the fact that a patent application will disclose technical information about the area in which the invention is claimed which may not be easily available to the Patent Office. By definition, an invention implies a thing not known or disclosed to the world at large. When the patent application is presented with new information, patent offices often face the problem of ascertaining the validity of the information. Despite being equipped with resources on technical and scientific information, patent offices throughout the world face difficulties in keeping pace with the rapid advancements made in all fields of technology. As the competitors of an inventor are likely to have more information about an invention, the law has devised a system of opposition where information with regard to an invention can be supplied by peers in the respective fields of technology. The information may pertain to an earlier invention or a disclosure that is more likely to come from the competitors who have expertise in that particular field of technology in which the invention is claimed. In sum, the device of opposition by competitors is a means to equip the Patent Office with information that may not be ordinarily available to it.
3Opposition proceedings will be significant in determining the grant of patents for the applications pending before the Patent Office. In the field of pharmaceutical patents, opposition proceedings are likely to play an important role not only in the development of patent law but also in the future of the pharmaceutical industry considering the large number of pharmaceutical patent applications pending before the Patent Office. During the ten-year transition period under the TRIPS, the Patent Office received a large number of applications through the mail-box, but reportedly there were only very few molecules invented during that period. (See NR Madhava Menon, ‘Indian Patent Law: Drawing on the Flexibility Offered by TRIPS’, in Ajit Parulekar and Sarita D’Souza (eds), Indian Patents Law–Legal and Business Implications, 2006, p 11. Some estimates show that there are more than 12,000 applications already filed in the Patent Office. See ‘Patently unclear; Intellectual property in India’, The Economist, 22 January 2005.) There could be many reasons for the disproportionate increase in the number of applications. Opposition is one of the methods by which the genuineness of these applications can be verified. In fact, the absence of opposition proceedings before the grant of EMR was regarded as the chief reason for the grant of monopoly rights to the EMR holders. Eventually, the EMR granted to Novartis’ Gleevac and to Wockhardt’s Nadoxin lapsed with the rejection of patent application by the Controller consequent to opposition proceedings initiated by its competitors. (See Novartis Application (1602/MAS/98); Wockhardt’s Application 2006 (32) PTC 261 (PO) (Mumbai).)
4Being the first instance of challenge to a patent application or a granted patent, opposition proceedings have certain distinct advantages over revocation proceedings available before a judicial authority. The merits of opposition proceedings are as follows.
5Being an in-house mechanism, opposition proceeding gives the opponent an opportunity to challenge a patent application or a granted patent before the authority that grants it. There are distinct advantages with regard to familiarity of subject, proficiency in technical knowledge, availability of resources for patent search etc that are available at the Patent Office.
6More often the device of opposition is put into effect by peers in the same industry who have knowledge about the field of technology relating to the invention. Pre-grant opposition proceedings permit a patent application to be challenged by any person. Though ‘any person’ includes an unrestricted array of persons, the technical nature of patents will permit only persons who have knowledge about the invention to pose a substantial challenge to it. Post-grant opposition can be instituted only by an interested person as defined under the Patents Act.
7The Patents Act and the Patents Rules stipulate specific time-limits for completing the opposition process efficiently. (Patents Act 1970, s 25 and Patents Rules 2003, rr 55 to 62 prescribes time-limits for bringing and concluding actions of pre-grant and post-grant opposition.) The underlying principle of opposition procedure is the early and complete presentation of the parties’ cases as opposed to the piecemeal and tardy introduction of arguments and supporting evidence. (See T326/87 Du Pont/Polyamide Composition [1991] EPOR 47.)
8The comparatively straightforward procedure of opposition proceedings result in quick disposal on merits, thereby reducing the costs incurred in contesting the proceedings. Trial and appreciation of evidence in the traditional manner in which it happens in the courts of law do not occur in opposition proceedings. Initially, there was no fee stipulated for filing a pre-grant opposition. However, after the 2014 amendment, a fee is now payable. The First Schedule prescribes, for the filing of a representation opposing grant of a patent under sub-section (1) of section 25, 8,000 rupees where the opponent is a natural person, startup, small entity or educational institution and 20,000 rupees in other cases, on e-filing, physical filing not being allowed (Patents Rules 2003, First Schedule, Table 1, entry 7A, inserted by the Patents (Amendment) Rules, 2014, in the First Schedule as substituted with effect from 4 November 2020).
9Sections 25 to 28 of the Patents Act deal with opposition. Rules 55 to 70 of the Patents Rules explain the procedural details. The present provisions on opposition proceedings in s 25 were introduced by the Patents (Amendment) Act 2005. Prior to its introduction, the chapter on opposition was titled ‘Opposition to the Grant of Patents’ and included grounds of opposition similar to those provided under s 25(1) of the Patents Act. The earlier provisions provided for opposition before the grant of a patent but were different from the pre-grant opposition proceedings introduced by the Patents (Amendment) Act 2005 as they required the opponent to give a notice of opposition to the Controller. Section 25 as it was before the Patents (Amendment) Act 2005 is still applicable to opposition proceedings instituted before the said amendment. The said amendment introduced a device for opposition after the grant which did not exist earlier under the Patents Act.
10Like many patent offices, the Indian Patent Office released a draft Manual of Patent Practice and Procedure in 2005 for providing guidelines for practice. It is stated therein that the contents of the Manual including the guidelines are for the purpose of illustration and not for legal purposes and in case of any conflict the Patents Act 1970 would prevail. Though guidelines stating the practice to be followed before the Patent Office would be desirable, it will not be legally binding in the absence of statutory backing. The experience in the EPO illustrates the beneficial effect of such guidelines where the Guidelines have some salutary purpose. The Opposition Division of the EPO is likely to view the precedents as having considerable weight, and the practice calls for the Boards of Appeal to account to the President of the EPO if they deviate from earlier case law, and to the parties, if they deviate from the Guidelines. (See art 15 of the Rules of Procedure of the Boards of Appeal, EPO.)
11The United Kingdom does not provide for opposition proceedings either before or after the grant, but it does provide for revocation of a granted patent. However, as a European Patent designating United Kingdom is treated as a patent granted by the UK Patent Office, the validity of grant of such a patent can be opposed at the EPO. (UK Patents Act 1977, s 77(1).) Articles 99 and 100 of the EPC provides for retrospective opposition after the grant, if the opposition is entered within nine months from the date of publication of the grant. Since opposition proceedings are open to all the contracting states, third party opposition proceedings under the EPO have become an attractive option to challenge a patent despite the delay involved. (Terrell on the Law of Patents, fifteenth edn, 2000, p 34.)
12The opposition mechanism available under the EPO provides a good illustration of the effectiveness of opposition proceedings. (For a detailed account on the working of opposition proceedings before the EPO, see Gwilym Roberts, ‘Oppositions before the European Patent Office’, 1999, vol 3, IPQ, pp 304-330.) As the EPC provides for a system of centralised post-grant opposition by third parties, the national laws of European countries do not have a mechanism for opposing patents. The opposition is entertained at the first instance by an Opposition Division of the EPO over which there is an appeal to the Board of Appeal. In rare cases, on points of law, there could be a further appeal to an Enlarged Board of Appeal. An opposition proceeding, if successful, may result in the revocation of the patent. The revocation may either be partial or total and will have effect in all the member states.
13The Opposition Division and the Board of Appeal are a part of the EPO. Members of the Boards are bound by the provision of the EPC. As there is no provision for further appeal from the decisions of the Board of Appeal, the opposition procedure under the EPC remains a powerful means to attain a conclusive and final result. The details of procedure are developed by a body of case law and practice derived from the decisions of the EPO.
14The effectiveness of European opposition proceeding makes it an ideal subject for a comparative study. The abundance of reported decisions and the similarity of legal provisions provide ample guidelines for developing an efficient system of opposition in India. In the year 2005, there were 2331 decisions in opposition cases given by the EPO. (European Patent Office, Annual Report, 2005, p 19.) Moreover, like the Patents Act, the EPC does not have detailed procedural guidelines for the conduct of opposition proceedings. Much of the procedural details have been developed by the EPO decisions rendered over a period of time. The system of developing procedural guidelines through decisions may be a practicable option in the absence of specific and detailed guidelines.
15As stated above, opposition proceedings under the Patents Act provide the first instance at which a challenge can be instituted against a patent. The Act provides for a multiple challenge mechanism. The multiple challenge mechanism is in conformity with the mandate of the TRIPS Agreement which provides for two broad forms of challenges to a patent. Article 62.4 of the TRIPS Agreement provides for procedures not inter partes (administrative revocation) and procedures inter partes (opposition, revocation and cancellation) for the acquisition and maintenance of patents. Broadly, challenge proceedings under the Patents Act can be classified into the two categories, ie: (1) opposition proceedings and (2) revocation proceedings.
16The purpose and intention of opposition proceedings is to give a competitor the opportunity of opposing unjustified protective rights. (See G01/91 Siemens/Unity in Opposition [1992] OJ EPO 253.) The Act provides for opposition at various stages before a right or a claim vests with a person. Opposition proceedings can be instituted to oppose amendments, restoration of lapsed patents, surrender of patents, corrections of clerical errors and grant of compulsory licence. Opposition proceedings may also be instituted to challenge the grant of a patent, either before or after the grant.
17In a sense the opposition proceedings can also be regarded as revocation proceedings as one of the possible outcome of an opposition proceeding is revocation of the patent. Yet opposition proceedings should be distinguished from revocation proceedings under the Patents Act, though both the proceedings can be maintained on certain common grounds and can result in the revocation of the patent, as the Act treats them separately. The Patents Act provides for two kinds of opposition proceedings:
(1) Opposition before the grant [s 25(1)] (2) Opposition after the grant [s 25(2)].
18The first instance of challenge to a patent comes in the form of opposition to the patent application under s 25(1) of the Patents Act. As this form of challenge is made at the application stage, the opponent must prefer its challenge before the Patent Office. This is commonly known as the pre-grant opposition. The second instance of challenge can be made soon after the patent is granted by the Patent Office. This form of challenge is made before the Patent Office and is commonly known as the post-grant opposition. The consequences of pre-grant opposition and post-grant opposition are different. If successful, a pre-grant opposition will result in the refusal of the patent application, whereas a successful post-grant opposition will result in the revocation of the patent granted, either in full or in part. (See the Patents Act 1970, s 15 and the Patents Rules 2003, r 55(5).) (Patents Act 1970, s 25(4).)
19A pre-grant opposition is initiated by filing a written representation for opposition before the appropriate office within the stipulated time. It is an opposition of a preliminary nature. Post-grant opposition is similar to revocation proceedings under s 64 in its outcome as both can have the effect of revoking the patent already granted. The significant difference being that the former is an option available at the Patent Office. Revocation proceedings under s 64 of the Patents Act 1970 now lie to the High Court. (Patents Act 1970, s 64(1), as amended by the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021).
20Apart from the above two provisions for opposing the grant of a patent, the Patents Act also provides for opposition procedure in general with regard to the following matters:
(1) Opposition to an application for amendment under s 57 [s 57(4)]; (2) Opposition to an application for restoration of lapsed patents under s 60 [s 61(1)]; (3) Opposition to the surrender of a patent under s 63 [s 63(3)]; (4) Opposition to the correction of clerical errors under s 78 [s 78(5)]; (5) Opposition to an application for the grant of compulsory licence under s 84 [s 87(2)]; (6) Opposition to an application for revocation of a patent for non-working under s 85 [s 87(2)]; and (7) Opposition to an application for revision of terms and conditions of compulsory licence under s 88(4) [r 101(3)].
21The challenge mechanism provided under opposition proceedings is time-bound as they have to be preferred within a time period stipulated under the Patents Act. (Pre-grant opposition proceeding can be initiated anytime before the grant of the patent. Rule 55(1A) provides that, notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1), no patent shall be granted before the expiry of a period of six months from the date of publication of the application under section 11A (Patents Rules 2003, r 55(1A)). Post-grant opposition proceeding has to be initiated within one year from the date of publication of grant.) Unlike opposition proceedings, revocation proceedings may be instituted at any time after the grant of the patent, while the patent is in force. The Act provides for revocation of patents in the following manner:
(1) Revocation by the Controller [ss 65 and 85]; (2) Revocation by high court [ss 64(1), 64(4) and 103]; (3) Revocation by the Central Government [ss 66 and 157A].
Provisions and topics
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/opposition