Akebia Therapeutics Inc. v Controller General of Patents, Design, Trademark and Geographical Indications (2023)
High Court of Delhi·C. Hari Shankar J·Single Judge·Decided 9 August 2023·2023 LiveLaw (Del) 688
Documents filed with a post-grant opposition without a supporting affidavit are not evidence under Rule 57: the Opposition Board's recommendations quashed and a fresh decision directed.
Akebia Therapeutics Inc. v Controller General of Patents, Design, Trademark and Geographical Indications, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/akebia
Summary
“On 26 September 2017, the petitioner’s Patent IN 287720 ... was granted by the Indian Patent Office in respect of an invention titled ‘HIF-1α prolyl hydroxylase inhibitor compounds’.” (para 1) “Post grant opposition under Section 25(2) of the Patents Act, 1970 read with Rule 57 of the Patents Rules, 2003 was filed by Respondent 3, in the present case, on 24 September 2018”, with “certain documents, without any accompanying affidavit.” (para 19) Then “on 14 February 2019, Respondent 3 filed a rejoinder to the reply statement filed by the petitioner on 15 January 2019, along with an affidavit of Poonam Raghuvanshi” (para 22). That “provoked the petitioner into moving a Miscellaneous Petition (‘MP-1’ hereinafter) before the learned Controller on 23 April 2019” (para 23), and then a “second Miscellaneous (hereinafter ‘MP-2’), seeking to place further evidence on record under Rule 60 of the Patents Rules.” (para 26) “MP-2 continues to languish, undecided, till date.” (para 28)
The Bench held that “mere documents, filed with the post grant opposition, cannot constitute ’evidence’ under the Patents Act or the Patents Rules” (para 10), and that “where the law requires an act to be done in a particular manner, the act has to be done in that manner alone, or not done at all” (para 11). The documents “cannot be regarded as documents allowed to be filed under Rule 57, i.e. as ’evidence’”, so “the Opposition Board could not have taken the said documents into consideration”, and “Respondent 3 having not filed any evidence under Rule 57, the petitioner was also denied the opportunity of filing reply evidence under Rule 58.” (para 32) Recommendations “which are crucial or which have great persuasive value” “have to be returned only after strict compliance with the procedural rules stipulated in that regard. Any failure to ensure such compliance has, in built in it, prejudice, and no separate prejudice needs to be shown” (para 34). “The recommendations of the Opposition Board, in the manner in which they came to be returned, cannot sustain. They are, therefore, quashed and set aside.” (para 35) “The petition stands allowed in the aforesaid terms.” (para 37)
What the court decided
- Evidence by affidavit. On Section 79 of the Patents Act the Bench held that “The Section is categorical in requiring evidence to be given by affidavit, subject to the power of the Controller to, in an appropriate case, permit oral evidence in lieu thereof. In any event, mere documents, filed with the post grant opposition, cannot constitute ’evidence’ under the Patents Act or the Patents Rules.” (para 10)
- The manner prescribed by law. “It is settled, from the times of Taylor v. Taylor, to the pronouncement of the Privy Council in Nazir Ahmed v. King Emperor, through a veritable plethora of decisions of the Supreme Court which have followed these dicta, that, where the law requires an act to be done in a particular manner, the act has to be done in that manner alone, or not done at all. All other methods of doing the act are necessarily forbidden.” (para 11)
- Rule 61 and the distinction. Rule 61, the Bench added, “also makes the distinction between the evidence, filed under Rules 57 to 60, and the documents referred to in the evidence, clear.” (para 12)
- No rejoinder under Rule 59. Adopting the contention of “Mr. Pravin Anand, learned Counsel for the petitioner”, the Bench held that “Rule 59 does not envisage, or permit, filing of any ‘rejoinder’ by the post grant opponent. It permits the post grant opponent to file evidence, and nothing more.” (para 15)
- What the Opposition Board considers. Under Rule 56(4) the Bench set out “(i) the post grant opposition along the evidence filed therewith, by the post grant opponent, under Rule 57, (ii) the reply statement, along with the evidence filed therewith, by the patentee, under Rule 58, (iii) the evidence filed by the post grant opponent under Rule 59, to meet the evidence filed by the patentee under Rule 58, and (iv) further evidence, if any, filed by either party” (para 17)
- Documents are not evidence. “Rule 57 envisages the filing only of a written statement/post grant opposition and evidence. Documents, unaccompanied by any supporting affidavit, do not constitute ’evidence’.” The Bench found that “The documents which were filed by Respondent 2 with its post grant opposition on 24 September 2018 were, therefore, filed in excess of the right to file documents” (para 32)
- The Board’s record under Rule 56(4). “Rule 56(4) requires the opposition board to examine the post grant opposition along with documents filed under Rules 57 to 60. Inasmuch as the documents filed by Respondent 2 with the post grant opposition on 24 September 2018 cannot be regarded as documents allowed to be filed under Rule 57, i.e. as ’evidence’, the Opposition Board could not have taken the said documents into consideration.” (para 32)
- The opportunity under Rule 58. “Had Respondent 3 actually filed the said documents as evidence under Rule 57, in accordance with Section 79 of the Patents Act - which is what the rule permitted Respondent 3 to do - the petitioner would have had an opportunity, under Rule 58, to file evidence by way of reply, to meet the evidence filed by Respondent 3. Respondent 3 having not filed any evidence under Rule 57, the petitioner was also denied the opportunity of filing reply evidence under Rule 58.” (para 32)
- A course foreign to the Rules. “It was only after the reply statement, unaccompanied by reply evidence, was filed by the petitioner under Rule 58 that, in a manner completely foreign to the Patents Rules, the Respondent 3 proceeded to file the affidavit of Ms. Poonam Raghuvanshi along with a rejoinder affidavit.” and “what ought to have been done by Respondent 3 on 24 September 2018 came to be done by Respondent 3 only on 14 February 2019.” (para 32)
- The record before the Board. “The failure, on the part of Respondent 3, to file any affidavit in support of the documents filed with the post grant opposition resulted in a situation in which the Opposition Board had with it only the documents irregularly filed by Respondent 3 on 24 September 2018, with no evidence in response from the side of the petitioner.” (para 32)
- The rejoinder affidavit. “The rejoinder affidavit would be required to be struck off the record, as Rule 59 does not permit the filing of any such affidavit” (para 32), and “The rejoinder affidavit filed by Respondent 3 on 22 May 2019 shall stand struck off the record.” (paras 32, 35)
- Prejudice and the Board’s report. “The Supreme Court, in Cipla, therefore, characterized the report of the Opposition Board as ‘crucial’.” The Bench held that recommendations “which are crucial or which have great persuasive value and which, therefore, tilt ... the scales in favour of one party or the other, have to be returned only after strict compliance with the procedural rules stipulated in that regard. Any failure to ensure such compliance has, in built in it, prejudice, and no separate prejudice needs to be shown by the party against whose interest the failure to observe the statutorily prescribed procedure has operated.” (paras 33–34)
- Disposition. The Bench disposed of the petition thus: “The recommendations of the Opposition Board, in the manner in which they came to be returned, cannot sustain. They are, therefore, quashed and set aside.” “The documents filed by Respondent 3 on 24 September 2018 are permitted to be treated as evidence led by Respondent 3 under Rule 57 on the basis of the affidavit of Poonam Raghuvanshi, which came to be filed on 14 February 2019.” “MP-2” (“Miscellaneous Petition”) “, filed by the petitioner on 7 February 2020, under Rule 60 for leading additional evidence is allowed. Additional evidence, in terms of the prayer contained in MP-2 may be filed by the petitioner within a period of four weeks from today.” “The additional evidence led by the petitioner shall be treated as evidence led in terms of Rule 58 of the Patents Rules.” “The matter would be placed before the Opposition Board, to take a fresh decision, de novo, after considering all the documents including the documents filed by Respondent 3 along with its post grant opposition on 24 September 2018, the affidavit of Poonam Raghuvanshi in support thereof, the reply statement filed by the petitioner on 14 February 2019 and the evidence, if any, which the petitioner would lead in accordance with the permission granted by this Court today.” and “The petition stands allowed in the aforesaid terms.” (paras 35, 37)
- Strict compliance hereafter. “The learned Controller General is requested to ensure that, hereafter, there is strict compliance with the provisions of the Patents Rules, particularly Rule 57, read with the judgment of the Supreme Court in Cipla, while dealing with and processing pre- or post-grant oppositions.” (para 38)
What the court did not decide
“We need not concern ourselves either with Section 25(1) of the Patents Act or with Rule 57(1) of the Patents Rules” (para 6), and on any further evidence, “In case either of the parties desires to lead any further evidence, that would have to abide by Rule 60 of the Patent Rules. A separate application would have to be moved in that regard and it would be for the Controller General to take a decision in that respect.” (para 35)
Subsequent treatment
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 28 October 2026.
Provisions and topics
Cited in
Case page · Page updated 7 November 2026
www.aop.onl/akebia