Doctrine page

Discretion in Allowing Amendment

On what basis is an amendment to a patent specification allowed or refused?

The Controller and the high court have discretion under sections 57 and 58, and are concerned with the conduct of the patentee and not with the merit of the invention.

Doctrine last updated on 18 November 2026

Cite this page

Discretion in Allowing Amendment, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/amendment-discretion

1The Controller and the high court have discretion in deciding whether an amendment should be allowed or not. In the exercise of such discretion, the following principles may be applicable: (See Smith Kline & French Laboratories Ltd v Evans Medical Ltd [1989] FSR 561, p 569.)

(1) Only such amendments will be allowed as are permitted under the Patents Act. (2) A patentee who seeks to obtain an unfair advantage from a patent, which ought to have been amended, will not be permitted to amend the same. For instance, if a patentee threatens an infringer based on his unamended patent where he knows that his patent ought to have been amended, it amounts to an unfair advantage. (3) The patentee must make full and fair disclosure of all relevant matters. The onus is on the patentee to show that the said amendment should be allowed. (4) The amendment should be sought for without undue delay to safeguard public interest. (5) In amendment proceedings, the court will be concerned with the conduct of the patentee and not with the merit of the invention.

2The applicant or the patentee, as the case may be, has a heavy burden to discharge while seeking an amendment. (See Chevron Research Co’s Patent [1970] FSR 357, p 362, (1970) RPC 580, p 586. See also SCM Corpn’s Application (1979) RPC 341, p 353 (CA); Du Pont de Nemours & Co’s (Robert’s) Patent (1972) RPC 545, p 550.) The onus is on the patentee to produce all the material to establish a case for amendment. Any failure to disclose the relevant matters may lead to refusal of the amendment. (See Smith Kline & French Laboratories Ltd v Evans Medical Ltd [1989] FSR 561, p 569.) The fact that no discovery was ordered for the production of certain documents does not mean that the applicant has discharged the onus. (See Hsiung’s Patent (1992) RPC 497, p 523 (CA).)

3Undue delay after a bona fide conviction that amendment is necessary or any delay which prejudices the interest of the defendant or the public may lead to the refusal of the amendment. (See Wilkinson Sword Ltd v Gillette Industries Ltd [1974] FSR 433, p 437, (1975) RPC 101, p 105.) Any unreasonable delay on the part of the patentee has to be explained satisfactorily. An amendment will be refused if the patentee knew about the unjustified width of its claim and deliberately maintained the same without carrying an amendment to ward off competitors. (See Wilkinson Sword Ltd v Gillette Industries Ltd [1974] FSR 433, p 436.)

4A patentee who knowingly allows an invalid claim to continue in his patent will not be later allowed to amend the claim. (See Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd (Whyte’s) Patent (1978) RPC 11, pp 22-23. See also Smith Kline & French Laboratories Ltd v Evans Medical Ltd [1989] FSR 561, p 569.) If the patentees were informed of a defect in the specification by an opponent and the patentees did not seek to amend their specification but successfully insisted in retaining it in its original form, it will not be open for the patentees to seek an amendment at a later point of time when the validity of the patent is attacked in revocation proceedings. (See IG Farbenindustrie AG’s Patent (1930) 47 RPC 289, p 325.) In the absence of evidence that the patentee was aware of the defect in his specification and was guilty of undue delay in applying for amendment, or that the patentee made use of the excessive scope of his claim to seek undue advantage over his competitors, the court shall allow the amendment. (See Chrome Alloying Co Ltd v Metal Diffusions Ltd (1962) RPC 33.)

5In AGC Flat Glass Europe v Anand Mahajan (2009) the Delhi High Court, on an application to amend claim 1 after the validity of the patent had been put in issue in an infringement suit, held that “It is settled law that if an amendment is put forward to overcome a possible objection to validity based upon a prior publication it may be relevant to consider whether the amendment propounded meets the objection arising out of such prior publication. If it does not, the amendment should be refused. If the patentee has known of the objection on the prior publication for many years, delay in applying for amendment will itself be ground for refusal.” (para 14) It held also that “It is also settled law that a patentee who had chosen to make his claim in a wide and sweeping form”, which the Court described as a covetous claim, “and who has had the advantage of the claim stated in that form for some years, may not be allowed to limit his claim by amendment to make his patent more secure.” (para 15) The amendment before it had been sought, on the defendants’ case, “after 12 years of grant of the patent” (para 9), and it was allowed without the delay rule being applied to it.

6If the patentees knew their claim was unjustifiably broad and failed to provide an explanation in spite of the opportunities given, the court will not allow an amendment of the specification at a later stage. (See Bentley Engineering Co Ltd’s Patent (1981) RPC 361, p 377.) If the patentee had obtained a patent or a part of a patent wrongfully from another, the patent will be revoked and no opportunity will be given to the patentee to amend the specification to the exclusion of the claims of which the patentee was not the true and first inventor.

7A successful opponent or a defendant will be entitled to costs from the patentee. (Patents Act 1970, s 58(1); Patents Rules 2003, r 81(3)(c).)

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cases on this page

Case page

AGC Flat Glass Europe SA v Anand Mahajan (2009)

High Court of Delhi·10 September 2009

See also

Doctrine page

Amendment Forum: Controller or Court

Can the Controller allow an amendment while an infringement suit or revocation petition is pending?

Doctrine page

Amendment Before the Controller

When can the Controller allow amendment of a patent application or specification?

Doctrine page

The Scope of Permissible Amendment

What amendments to a patent application or specification are permitted under section 59?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/amendment-discretion