Doctrine page

Amendment Forum: Controller or Court

Can the Controller allow an amendment while an infringement suit or revocation petition is pending?

The Controller shall not exercise his power to amend pending any infringement suit or revocation proceedings, section 58 giving the high court the power to allow amendments in revocation proceedings.

Doctrine last updated on 18 November 2026

Cite this page

Amendment Forum: Controller or Court, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/amendment-forum

1Section 58 of the Patents Act gives the high court the power to allow amendments in revocation proceedings. While the Controller has the power to carry out amendments both before and after the grant under s 57, the opportunity to amend under s 58 is confined only to issues arising out of a revocation proceeding. Though infringement proceedings are not expressly mentioned in s 58, it can be inferred from the language of the proviso to s 57(1), that the power of the high court to amend extends to amendments carried out during infringement proceedings. This was also the case in the United Kingdom, where the corresponding provision in the UK Patents Act 1949 extended the power of amendment to infringement proceedings as well. (UK Patents Act 1949, s 30.)

2Section 58 deals with amendment of complete specification pending proceedings before the high court. The Patents Act clearly demarcates the powers of the Controller to carry out amendments and bars the Controller from passing any order in an application for amendment during the pendency of infringement or revocation proceeding. The proviso to s 57(1) provides that the Controller shall not exercise his power to amend under that sub-section pending any infringement suit or revocation proceedings, whether such suit or proceeding was commenced before or after the filing of the application to amend. (Patents Act 1970, s 57(1).) On the introduction of the said proviso, Justice Ayyangar had commented in his report: (See Justice N Rajagopala Ayyangar, ‘Report on the Revision of the Patent Laws’, September 1959, para 559.)

The point of distinction between the provision in the Indian Patents and Designs Act 1911 and the Bill is that under the former, a proceeding had to be pending in a court at the date of filing of the application to amend, in order that the jurisdiction of the Controller should be ousted, whereas under the sub-clause the bar is directed to orders being passed on an application to amend – whenever this be filed – if proceedings before the court are pending at the date of such order. The inconvenience of the former rule is illustrated by the decision in Re: Western Electric Co Ltd (50 RPC 59) where a petition to the Court to revoke a patent was sought to be countered by an application for amendment filed 5 days earlier. Justice Eve after stating that since the application to amend was filed when there was no ‘proceeding pending before the Court’, the patentee was not disentitled to proceed with his application, observed – ‘No doubt that application would have to be dealt with before the petition for revocation can be satisfactorily disposed’, and directed the petition to stand over till the disposal of the application, imposing however, on the patentee conditions requiring him to prosecute the amendment application with diligence.

3The expression ‘pending’ in s 57(1) of the Patents Act refers to any suit or proceeding before the high court which has been initiated but not yet decided. The expression ‘must be read in a narrower sense and requires that there must be some question outstanding on which the court is still required to exercise its jurisdiction’. (See Critchley Brothers Ltd v Engelmann & Buckham Ltd (1971) RPC 346, p 347, [1971] FSR 228, p 230. See also Lever Bros and Unilever Ltd’s Patent (No 5) (1955) 72 RPC 198, p 205 (CA), where it was observed that ‘where the settlement is not final but conditional only – for example, conditional upon some specified amendment to the specification of the patent being approved – then so long as the condition is unfulfilled the result may well be different, for in such case it cannot be said that the issues relating to infringement or revocation have been finally disposed of; the question of the determination of such issues is in effect adjourned pending the performance of the condition, and in case of non-performance will remain unresolved’.) Pending action means an action before judgment. A suit or a proceeding cannot be said to be pending the moment the court pronounces its judicial decision. (Re National Carbon Co Incorporated AIR 1934 Cal 725, p 729, a case decided under the Patents and Designs Act 1911.)

4Subject to the provisions of s 59 and to such terms as to costs, advertisement etc, as may be stipulated, the high court may allow the patentee to amend its complete specification. In any revocation proceedings, if the high court holds that patent is invalid, it may allow the amendment of the specification instead of revoking the patent. (Patents Act 1970, s 58(1).) Such an amendment may be done by deleting an invalid claim, with consequential alteration to the body of the specification. (See Van der Lely NV v Bramfords Ltd (1964) RPC 54 (CA).) (See Raleigh Cycle Co Ltd v H Miller & Co Ltd (1949) 66 RPC 253 (CA).)

5The language used in s 58 indicates that the court has the discretion to allow or refuse an amendment, which must be exercised taking into account the material facts. (See Chiron Corpn v Organon (No 7) [1994] FSR 458, p 460.) In exercising such discretion, attention must be paid to the nature of the amendments sought, as the courts have held that there is a material difference between deletion of claims and validation by reformulation and shown an inclination to more readily allow the former than the latter. (Ibid. See also Van der Lely NV v Bramfords Ltd (1964) RPC 54 (CA).) In allowing amendments under s 58, the high court may impose certain terms and conditions. Such conditions may be based on case of revocation which led to the amendment. The power of amendment under s 58 can be exercised after the grant of a patent where amendment is exercised as an option instead of revoking the patent. (See Patents Act 1970, s 52(1) for one instance of such an amendment.)

6The power of the high court to amend can be exercised in revocation proceedings or in infringement proceedings where a counter-claim for revocation is raised. The Patents Act provides that the grounds of revocation may be taken as a defence in an infringement suit. (Ibid, s 107.) In effect, the revocation proceeding before the high court is nothing but the counter-claim of revocation taken in an infringement suit. This would fortify the argument that s 58 covers infringement proceedings as well. Though a suit for infringement can be filed either in the district court or the high court, if a defendant in such a suit raises a counter-claim of revocation, the suit along with the counter-claim shall be transferred to the high court. (Patents Act 1970, s 104.)

7In OpenTV v Controller of Patents and Designs (2023), an appeal from a refusal by the Controller, the Delhi High Court recorded of Societe Des Produits Nestle v Controller of Patents and Design (2023) that “since the Controller has the power of directing amendment to a patent application, a High Court in appeal would also have similar powers. It also observed that the appeal is a continuation of the proceedings before the original forum and thus, amendments are permissible at the appellate stage.” (para 52) It held that “irrespective of whether the amendment is directed by the Court or is at the instance of Patent Applicant, so long as the requirements as laid down under Section 59 of the Act are fulfilled such that the amended claims are within the scope of original claims, is not breached, the amendment is permissible.” (para 53) and that “there is no embargo on permitting a Patent Applicant to amend claims even at the appellate stage” (para 60).

8In AGC Flat Glass Europe v Anand Mahajan (2009), on an application under sections 57 and 58 made in the infringement suit itself, the Delhi High Court held that “The law which emanates from the authorities cited is quite akin to the law of amendment. The jurisdiction necessary to allow the amendment of a claim in the specification vests with the High Court, once the validity of the patent has been challenged in a patent infringement suit.” (para 17) The defendants’ objection that the application “has not been filed at the appropriate forum as provided under Section 57 of the Patents Act, 1970” (para 7) failed, and the amendment was allowed as “merely a clarificatory/ elaborative one” which “does not attract the proviso of Section 58 and 59 of the Patent Act, 1970.” (para 25)

9When the patentee amends the patent after a successful infringement action, he must initiate a fresh action rather than seeking to enforce any relief obtained through an action before the amendment. Where the patentee seeks leave to amend the specification pending revocation proceedings, the court may impose conditions on the patentee that it should not bring or maintain any action for infringement in respect of acts committed before the date of the order. (See Ludington Cigarette Machine Co v Baron Cigarette Machine Co [1900] 1 Ch 508 (CA).) Amendments carried out pending infringement proceedings will restrict the chances of obtaining damages or accounts of profits. Where an amendment of a specification is made by way of a disclaimer, correction or explanation after the publication of the specification, no damages or account of profits shall be granted in any proceeding in respect of use of the invention before the date of the decision allowing the amendment, unless the court is satisfied that the specification as originally published was framed in good faith and with reasonable skill and knowledge. (Patents Act 1970, s 111(3).) In other words, if the patent is not framed with reasonable skill and knowledge, the patentee will be unable to recover damages for past infringements. (See Mabuchi Motor KK’s Patent (1996) RPC 387, p 402, [1996] FSR 93.)

10The patentee must demonstrate good faith and reasonable skill and knowledge. In the absence of any evidence to the contrary, the court may presume that the original specification was drawn with good faith and reasonable skill and knowledge. But any evidence which indicates the lack of good faith will be reason enough to disallow the amendment. (See Molins and Molins Machine Co Ltd v Industrial Machinery Co Ltd (1938) 55 RPC 31, p 33, [1937] 4 All ER 295 (CA), a case decided under s 23 of the UK Patents and Designs Act 1907 which corresponds to s 111(3) of the Patents Act.) Good faith is a question of a fact and a patentee will not be able to show good faith in making the original specification if he had knowingly sought to include a field of subject matter beyond what he had invented. (See Kane & Pattison v J Boyle Co (1901) 18 RPC 325, p 338. See also David Kahn Inc v Conway Stewart and Co Ltd [1972] FSR 620, (1974) RPC 279.) Since amendments can have retrospective effect, the Controller may impose conditions on an action of infringement with regard to acts done by the opponent before the date of application of the leave to amend, which the patentee may be entitled to bring in the light of the amendment. (See Deeley v Perkes [1896] AC 496, p 499, (1896) 13 RPC 581; Andrew v Crossley (1892) 9 RPC 165, [1892] 1 Ch 492. See also Ludington Cigarette Machine Co v Baron Cigarette Machine Co [1900] 1 Ch 508 (CA).)

11Compared to the powers of the Controller under s 57, the scope of amendment under s 58 is relatively restricted. First, the power to amend under s 58 is limited to the patentee’s complete specification alone. It does not cover application for a patent or any other document as in the case of s 57. Secondly, the power under s 58 can be invoked only in a revocation proceeding and shall be confined to issues arising out of such revocation proceedings. Thirdly, as an amendment under s 58 is made in response to a revocation proceeding instituted by a third party, such amendments cannot be regarded as voluntary amendments in the strict sense of the term. Section 58, however, gives a limited option to the patentee in allowing him to amend his complete specification before a decision is made in the revocation proceedings. If the patentee does not exercise this option, the high court may still allow the patentee to amend his specification instead of revoking the patent, if it comes to a decision that the patent in its unamended form is invalid. (Patents Act 1970, s 58(1).) **

12It is expected that the high court will allow such amendment where there is a curable defect. For instance, where the patent has been challenged in revocation proceedings on the ground that the complete specification does not disclose, or wrongly mentions, the source or geographical origin of the biological material used in the invention, a proper disclosure should be capable of curing such a defect. (Ibid, s 64(1)(p).) Thus, if the defect in the patent is incurable, ie, the invalid patent cannot be made valid by an amendment, an amendment will be refused. (See Hennebique’s Patent (1911) 28 RPC 41, where the patent was declared invalid for want of subject matter and that that patent would have been bad even if the claim had been as narrowly drafted as was proposed in the amendment.) Similarly, the court will not allow an amendment which would leave a patent invalid. (See Pharmacia Corpn v Merck & Co Inc [2001] EWCA Civ 1610, (2002) RPC 41, para 146 (CA).)

13The applicant shall give notice to the Controller in such proceedings and the Controller shall be entitled to appear and be heard. The Controller shall appear if directed by the high court. (Patents Act 1970, s 58(2).) All the copies of the orders allowing amendment under s 58 shall be transmitted to the Controller who shall make appropriate corrections in the register. (Ibid, s 58(3).)

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cases on this page

Case page

OpenTV Inc v Controller of Patents and Designs (2023)

High Court of Delhi·11 May 2023

Case page

Societe Des Produits Nestle SA v Controller of Patents and Design (2023)

High Court of Delhi·3 February 2023

Case page

AGC Flat Glass Europe SA v Anand Mahajan (2009)

High Court of Delhi·10 September 2009

See also

Doctrine page

Discretion in Allowing Amendment

On what basis is an amendment to a patent specification allowed or refused?

Doctrine page

Amendment Before the Controller

When can the Controller allow amendment of a patent application or specification?

Doctrine page

Leave to Amend Obtained by Fraud

Can a patent be revoked if leave to amend the specification was obtained by fraud?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/amendment-forum