Mere Arrangement or Re-arrangement
Can a patent be granted for arranging known devices together?
Latest update: . Case: Ab Initio Technology LLC v Assistant Controller of Patents. Doctrine: Appeals from the Controller.
When is a combination of known substances a mere admixture under section 3(e)?
Under section 3(e), any substance obtained by a mere admixture cannot be regarded as an invention if it results only in the aggregation of the properties of the components.
Doctrine last updated on 10 October 2026
Mere Admixture, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/mere-admixture
1Any substance obtained by a mere admixture cannot be regarded as an invention if it results only in the aggregation of the properties of the components. Similarly, a process for producing such a substance shall not be regarded as an invention. A mixture of different kinds of medicines, forming a cocktail of drugs, to cure multiple diseases will not be a patentable invention. For instance, a composition of two drugs, ie, Paracetamol (Acetaminophen) and Ibuprofen for curing fever and pain or a process of preparation thereof, will not be patentable as the composition is a mere admixture of two drug components resulting in an aggregation of analgesic and anti-inflammatory actions of their respective components. But a distinction has been drawn with regard to admixture resulting in synergistic properties. The Patent Office does not consider an admixture which results in unexpected results or synergistic properties as a ‘mere’ admixture and may regard such mixtures to be patentable. (See Manual of Patent Practice and Procedure, Patent Office.)
Can a patent be granted for arranging known devices together?
Can an invention based on traditional knowledge be patented in India?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/mere-admixture