Case page

Dr Tarkeshwar Chandrakant Patil v Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay (2026)

High Court of Bombay·Somasekhar Sundaresan J·Single Judge·Decided 8 September 2026·2026:BHC-OS:19905

Good law Appeal allowed; the refusal of 17 July 2025 quashed, the pre-grant opposition allowed, Patil substituted as applicant and the application restored for decision on merits within eight weeks by a different senior officer. No further appeal traced as of 27 October 2026.

An institution that assigned an invention worldwide to its inventor wrongfully obtained it by pursuing the Indian application: refusal quashed, inventor substituted as applicant, merits remitted.

Cite this page

Dr Tarkeshwar Chandrakant Patil v Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/patil

Judgment PDF

Summary

“This Petition is essentially a statutory appeal under Section 117A of the Patents Act, 1970 (’the Act’), impugning an order dated July 17, 2025” by which “Patent Application No. 2808/MUM/2013 dated August 28, 2013” “has been rejected by a Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs” (para 1). The petitioner “is admittedly an original inventor of the proposed patent, and named as such in the Patent Application, which was filed by the Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay (‘IITB’)”; “The invention is titled ‘An Apparatus and a Method for In-Vivo Power Generation’” (para 2). “Eventually, on July 3, 2017, IITB executed the Deed of Assignment in favour of Patil, an instrument titled ‘Assignment - Worldwide’” (para 33). “The Controller indeed recognised Patil as the applicant on the strength of the worldwide assignment, allowing his Form 6 on November 15, 2017” and “Within three weeks, that order was withdrawn by an order dated December 28, 2017, on the footing that IITB’s own proof of right from the inventors had never been filed and that an assignment by IITB to Patil could therefore not be considered.” (para 19) Patil “filed a Pre-Grant Opposition on June 17, 2019, invoking Sections 25(1) and 26 of the Act” (para 72), and the impugned order dismissed it and refused the application “since the requirement u/s 7(2) is not met” (para 60).

The Court held “that by reason of the Deed of Assignment executed by IITB in favour of Patil, IITB has no residual right, title or interest in the Patent Application” (para 18). “Once the Deed of Assignment was executed, the continued pursuit of the Patent Application by IITB in its own name was wrongful.” (para 92) “The Pre-Grant Opposition filed by Patil under Section 25(1)(a) of the Act is allowed by declaring that Patil be recognised as the inventor and applicant in the Patent Application” and “The Impugned Order dated July 17, 2025 is quashed and set aside in its entirety” (para 104). “The Patent Application is restored to the file of the Controller with Patil substituted as the applicant in place of IITB” (para 104).

What the court decided

  1. Appellate power and title. “In exercise of the appellate powers under Section 117A, this Court being clothed with the concurrent and co-extensive powers as those available to the Controller, I have no hesitation in holding that by reason of the Deed of Assignment executed by IITB” (“Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay”) “in favour of Patil, IITB has no residual right, title or interest in the Patent Application. The inexorable conclusion is that Patil must be treated as the owner of the invention and the Patent Application, as if filed by Patil, must be processed and dealt with in accordance with law by the Controller in a time-bound manner.” (para 18)
  2. Assent to the institution’s policy. Clause I of the policy provided that “IITB owns all the Intellectual Property (IP) that is produced by all IITB personnel” (para 24), and “There can be no quarrel that Patil would fit the definition of the term ‘IITB Personnel’.” (para 25) “To my mind, by executing the aforesaid provision in the Revenue Sharing Agreement, Patil had confirmed being bound by the IP Policy.” “It would not matter that a stipulated form of an agreement to be bound by the IP Policy was not signed.” (para 29) “Patil’s contention that the IP Policy did not bind him for want of a signed IP Policy Agreement Form is rejected” (paras 24–25, 29, 104)
  3. Authority to waive and assign. “IITB’s assignment, acting through the Dean, R&D” (“Dean, Research and Development of IITB”) “is consistent with the IP Policy.” (para 36) “By executing the Deed of Assignment, the Dean, R&D waived the inherent position in the IP Policy that all intellectual property of invention pursuant to research by IITB Personnel vested in IITB.” (paras 36, 46)
  4. Territorial reach of the assignment. “The terms of the Deed of Assignment are crystal clear. All rights of IITB not only in the patent application in USA” (“United States of America”) “but also in other jurisdictions were assigned.” (para 35) “Worse, the contention is that countries foreign to USA cannot include India and would only cover all countries other than India that are foreign to USA. This is wholly absurd and inflicts serious violence not just to the language of a legally binding instrument but also to plain logic and reason.” (para 45) “There is no rational basis to contend that such an absolute assignment is valid for USA and countries foreign thereto, but excludes India.” (paras 35, 45, 55)
  5. The ownership exemption clause. “A plain reading of Clause 13 would show that the Deed of Assignment is aligned with Clause 13 of the IP Policy.” (para 53) The question “whether there has been use of ‘significant resources’ of IITB” (para 53) “is a debate that need not be resolved. All these controversies are irrelevant since IITB has consciously executed the Deed of Assignment.” (paras 53–54)
  6. The funding body’s claim. “Therefore, what is clear is that CSIR” (“Council of Scientific and Industrial Research”) “did not assert any title to Patil’s inventive research work.” (para 50) “Therefore, the CSIR Undertaking dated March 21, 2013 does not detract from Patil’s title” (paras 50, 104)
  7. The foreign grant. “It is not the grant of registration in USA that led to IITB giving up its right to the invention.” “The grant of patent in USA exclusively to Patil is a consequence of that contractual binding commitment executed by IITB for assignment worldwide.” (para 51)
  8. Prospective operation of the assignment. “The Impugned Order holds that the Deed of Assignment does not have retrospective effect to affect prior assignments – an entirely fallacious approach since the Deed of Assignment is prospective and takes effect from its execution, particularly considering it is a reversal of the ownership, it prospectively overrides all past arrangements between the parties.” (para 88) “The Deed of Assignment operates prospectively from its execution; from that date Patil is the sole owner of the invention and of the Patent Application, and no question of retrospectivity arises or is relevant” (paras 88, 104)
  9. The duty-to-invent reasoning. Darius Rutton Kavasmaneck v. Gharda Chemicals Ltd. “is not a decision of the Supreme Court but of a Learned Single Judge (2014 SCC OnLine Bom 1851) and of a Learned Division Bench of this Court (2015 SCC OnLine Bom 4813)” and “It has no bearing on the instant case, where IITB, the employer, has by a written instrument assigned that title to Patil, the inventor” (para 59). “The Deed of Assignment cannot be resiled from, and certainly not by the Controller writing its own worldview on rights of employers over employees’ inventions” (paras 55, 59)
  10. Wrongful obtainment. “This provision pits the applicant and the opponent against each other. Once the Deed of Assignment was executed, the continued pursuit of the Patent Application by IITB in its own name was wrongful. Such pursuit made IITB’s claim to the invention, after the Deed of Assignment, a case of wrongful obtainment.” (para 92) “This institutional decision has to be honoured and respected and if it is mechanically ignored, that is squarely subject matter of adjudication under Section 25(1)(a).” (paras 92–93)
  11. Non-application of mind. “The Impugned Order invokes IITB’s IP Policy but simply does not deal with how the Deed of Assignment is consistent with the IP Policy” (para 89), and “the Impugned Order suffers from complete non-application of mind to the merits of Patil’s contentions relating to ownership of the invention.” (para 89)
  12. The floodgates argument. “This argument has to be rejected since in this case the IP Policy has indeed been applied and in letting it operate consistently and in compliance with its terms, IITB has waived and assigned its rights to Patil.” (para 94)
  13. Opposition and examination as two tracks. “The only logical and commonsensical sequencing of the hearings would be to determine the objection under Section 25(1)(a) of the Act and then proceed with the adjudication under Sections 14 and 15 of the Act. Indeed, each is a distinct track – Section 25(1)(a) covers a bilateral conflict between the applicant and the opponent while Section 14 and Section 15 cover an in rem implication of the merits of protection.” (para 97) Where “there are two competing claimants to title”, “the Controller would need to engage with each of the claimants on the merits so that its comprehensive final order is truly meaningful.” (para 98) “If the Controller does not desire to adjudicate and rule under Section 25(1)(a) as a first step, in a factual matrix such as this case, it would need to hear both claimants on the merits under Section 14 and Section 15 of the Act so that the integrity of due process and natural justice is not compromised.” (paras 97–98, 100)
  14. An opponent heard by order. “When Patil was given a seat at the table by the Division Benches of the High Court, he was not meant to sit there as a mute spectator.” (para 101)
  15. Disposition and directions. “IITB’s continued pursuit of the Patent Application in its own name after July 3, 2017 was wrongful. The Impugned Order dated July 17, 2025 is quashed and set aside in its entirety” and “Patil’s Form 6 and Form 13 dated October 31, 2017 stand allowed. The Controller shall process the Patent Application on merits under Sections 14 and 15 of the Act, after hearing Patil as the applicant on the objections in the FER” (“First Examination Report”) “dated July 25, 2019 and any further objections, and shall pass a final reasoned order within eight weeks” with “a senior officer other than the officer who passed the Impugned Order” to “proceed uninfluenced by the Impugned Order, the order dated December 28, 2017 and the Dhumane Email” (para 104)
  16. The proof-of-right impasse. “Put simply, the Controller refused to recognise Patil as the applicant because IITB’s proof of right from Patil had never been filed, and also refused IITB’s application for the very same reason – an endorsement in IITB’s favour that Patil, claiming to be the owner under IITB’s own assignment, could never have been expected to give.” (para 61)

What the court did not decide

“Nothing in this Judgement is an expression of an opinion on merits of the Patent Application” (para 104)

Subsequent treatment

No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 27 October 2026.

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cited in

Doctrine page

Appeals from the Controller

Doctrine page

Assignment

Doctrine page

Pre-grant Opposition

Doctrine page

Proof of Right

Doctrine page

Wrongful Obtaining

Doctrine page

Examination and the First Examination Report

Case page · Page updated 8 November 2026

www.aop.onl/patil