Doctrine page

Wrongful Obtaining

What must an opponent prove to show that an invention was wrongfully obtained?

Under sections 25(1)(a) and 25(2)(a) an application or patent may be opposed where the invention was wrongfully obtained from the opponent, and it has to be proved beyond reasonable doubt.

Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026

Cite this page

Wrongful Obtaining, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/wrongful-obtaining

1An application for a patent or a granted patent may be opposed on the ground that the applicant for the patent or the patentee had wrongfully obtained the invention or any part thereof from the opponent. The provisions of the above sections are slightly different from s 64(1)(c) of the Patents Act. The wording in ss 25(1)(a) and 25(2)(a) refers to an ‘invention’ wrongfully obtained, whereas s 64(1)(c) refers to a ‘patent’ obtained wrongfully.

2‘Obtaining the invention’ means finding out about the nature of the invention. (See International Carbon Corpn’s Application (1975) RPC 365, p 371, [1972] FSR 547.) The expression ‘obtained the invention’ has its focus on the identity of the invention and not on the right of the person from whom it was obtained as the first and true inventor. It means to obtain the invention which is purported to be patented. In cases of ‘obtaining’, it is not necessary that the alleged true and first inventor must be joined as a party to the opposition. It is sufficient if the entity which has interest in the invention opposes the same. (See Official Ruling (B)(1923) 40 RPC App p iii, where it was held that a limited company which had acquired an interest from another person was entitled to give notice of opposition on the strength of the acquired interest.)

3In deciding cases on ‘obtaining’, the first step should be to determine the person to whom the invention belonged at the time when obtaining took place and then to determine whether such invention (assuming the invention to be the opponent’s invention) came from the opponent to the applicant. (See International Carbon Corpn’s Application (1975) RPC 365, p 370.) Under the Patents Act, the true and first inventor or his assignee or legal representative can be the applicant. Any other person will not be entitled to prefer an application. In cases where an application is preferred by a person who has imported the invention from abroad, the same may be opposed on the ground of wrongful obtaining by the inventor, as the Patents Act excludes an importer from being an applicant. (Patents Act 1970, ss 2(1)(y) and 6.)

4The first step applies as much to an applicant that has parted with title as to one that took the invention from another. In Dr Tarkeshwar Chandrakant Patil v Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay (2026), the inventor’s objection being under section 25(1)(a), the Bombay High Court held that “This provision pits the applicant and the opponent against each other. Once the Deed of Assignment was executed, the continued pursuit of the Patent Application by IITB in its own name was wrongful. Such pursuit made IITB’s claim to the invention, after the Deed of Assignment, a case of wrongful obtainment.” (para 92) The conflict between the research student and his guide having been escalated and “led to the Dean, R&D waiving IITB’s interest in the invention”, it held that “This institutional decision has to be honoured and respected and if it is mechanically ignored, that is squarely subject matter of adjudication under Section 25(1)(a)” (para 93).

5The burden of proving the grounds in post-grant opposition will lie on the opponent. The fact that the invention was wrongfully obtained will be for the opponent to prove. In cases where the opponent alleges the invention was obtained by the applicant through intermediary parties, the opponent will have to prove that there was an essential connection between the applicant and his agent, and that they were in a relationship which seemed to justify such communication of the invention. (See Official Ruling (A) (1910) 27 RPC App p iv.)

6For an application to be refused on this ground, it has to be proved beyond reasonable doubt that the invention was wrongfully obtained from another. (See Standard Motor Co Ltd’s Patent (1954) 71 RPC 251, p 252.) Where doubts exist with regard to whether the invention or the patent is wrongfully obtained, the application will be allowed to proceed or the patent granted will be allowed to remain, as there exists further opportunity available to revoke the patent. (See Staurt’s Application (1892) 9 RPC 452.) In any case, the existence of suspicious circumstances, such as an alleged breach of confidence, will not be reason enough to conclude that the invention was wrongfully obtained. (See Formulast Corpn’s Application (1970) RPC 243, p 254.)

7Where the opponent was the true and first inventor and had communicated the complete specification to the applicant, it will be for the applicant to show that the subject matter of the application was independently invented by the applicant prior to such communication. (See H’s Application (1956) RPC 197, pp 198-9.) Similarly, where the opponent alleges that the invention was obtained from him and the applicant, in response, states that the invention was communicated to him from abroad, the applicant must prove that there was indeed a communication from abroad. (Ibid.)

8The relief a post-grant opponent can claim in cases where the invention is wrongfully obtained from the opponent is mentioned in s 26 of the Patents Act. The relief includes amending the patent in the name of the opponent, revoking or making a disclaimer of the part of the invention wrongfully obtained. The relief contained in s 26 is in the form of a personal remedy. Where prior public use is established, the opponent cannot claim a personal remedy in his favour. The Controller may revoke the patent on the ground of wrongful obtaining and may direct amendment of the patent in the name of the opponent. Where a part of an invention was obtained wrongfully from the opponent, the Controller may pass an order requiring the specification to be amended by the exclusion of that part of the invention. In such cases, if the opponent has filed an application for a patent for an invention which includes the whole or part of the invention so wrongfully obtained from him, he shall be entitled to the same priority as the earlier application. (Patents Act 1970, s 26(2).) For all other purposes, the application of the opponent shall proceed as an independent application filed under the Patents Act. An opponent will not be allowed a claim wider than that claimed in the application opposed. (X Ltd’s Application [1982] FSR 143, p 145 (CA).)

Provisions and topics

Provisions

Cases on this page

See also

Doctrine page

The True and First Inventor

Who is a true and first inventor under section 2(1)(y) of the Patents Act?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/wrongful-obtaining