Vringo Infrastructure Inc v Indiamart Intermesh Ltd (2014)
High Court of Delhi·5 August 2014
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
What must a patent plaint plead about infringement before the court will grant relief?
Under Order VI rule 4 of the Code, the particulars of infringement in a patent suit must be specific, and relief follows only where its necessary foundation has been pleaded.
Doctrine last updated on 13 November 2026
Pleadings and Particulars, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/pleadings
1Every suit shall be framed in such a manner so as to afford ground for final decision upon the subject matter of dispute, and to prevent further litigation concerning them. (Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O 2, r 1.) The suit shall include the whole claim which the plaintiff is entitled to make in respect of the cause of action, but the plaintiff may omit certain relief with the leave of the court and bring action with regard to such relief subsequently. (Ibid, O 2, r 2. See also para 20.81.) The plaintiff will also be entitled to join together causes of action. (Ibid, O 2, r 3.) Any objection on the ground of misjoinder of causes of action shall be taken at the earliest instance, before the issues are settled in the suit. (Ibid, O 2, r 7.)
2Pleadings include the plain and the written statement. The pleadings shall generally state the material facts and not the evidence. The general rules of pleading contained in O 6 can be summarised as follows: (See Mulla’s Code of Civil Procedure, seventeenth edn, 2007, vol 2, p 273.)
(i) State your whole case in your pleading, in other words, set forth in your pleading all material facts on which you rely for your claim or defence (r 2). (ii) State facts and not law (r 2). If any matter of law is set out in your opponent’s pleading, do not plead it. (iii) State the material facts on which you rely, and not the evidence by which they are to be proved (rr 2, 10, 11, 12). (iv) State material facts only; omit immaterial and unnecessary facts. Do not anticipate your opponent’s pleading and plead to any matter which is not alleged against you (r 2). (v) State the facts of your case concisely, but with precision (r 2). (vi) It is not necessary to allege the performance of any condition precedent; an averment of performance is implied in every pleading (r 6). (vii) It is not necessary to set out the whole or any part of a document, unless the precise words thereof are necessary. It is sufficient to state the effect of the document as briefly as possible (r 9). (viii) It is not necessary to allege any matter of fact which the law presumes in one’s favour, or as to which the burden of proof lies upon your opponent (r 13).
3In Vringo Infrastructure v Indiamart Intermesh (2014) the Delhi High Court held that “A party cannot be permitted to raise an argument which is not even pleaded. Rejoinder is an opportunity given to the plaintiffs for explanation, refutation, implication and not to set up a new case.” (para 34) In Conqueror Innovations v Xiaomi Technology India (2026) the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court found “the pleading at paragraph 34 of the plaint is at variance with the written submissions of the Appellant placed before us” and held that “the stand now taken by the Appellants is a post-facto reconsideration of their infringement claims in view of the negative findings returned by the learned Single Judge on infringement of Element E2.” (para 25)
4In Lallubhai Chakubhai Jarivala v Shamaldas Sankalchand Shah (1934), where an issue of prior public user had been widened after the plaintiff closed his case and no particulars were given, the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court held that the amendment of the issue “ought not to have been allowed after the close of the plaintiff’s case” (para 5). It held that “Now the Court undoubtedly has a discretion to allow an amendment of the pleadings or the issues or to raise fresh issues at any stage of the case. But, if the course to be taken is not fair to the party against whom it is to be taken, or would take him by surprise, then, obviously, the Court ought to have given him a proper opportunity to meet the new case.” It held that “if it was felt that in the interests of justice it was necessary, the Court should have directed the defendant to give particulars. In a patent case the necessity of proper particulars is all the greater”, and that “Order VI, Rule 4, of the Civil Procedure Code, specifically lays down the same principle.” (para 38)
5In Ace Technologies v Communication Components Antenna (2023), where the plaintiff had reserved a right to bring further models of the infringing article into the suit but had taken no step to amend, the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court held that “the plaintiff cannot be granted any relief unless the necessary foundation for seeking such relief has been pleaded and the defendant has had an opportunity to contest the same.” (para 81) It held that “There is no provision in the CPC, which permits the plaintiff to press an actionable claim by filing an affidavit during a subsequent stage in the suit, without amending the plaint.” (para 82) And it held that “We are unable to accept that filing an affidavit during the pendency of the suit can be a substitute for amendment of the pleadings. A prayer for relief, which is not supported by pleadings and evidence, cannot be granted.” (para 83)
6Every plaint shall be filed in duplicate and shall comply with the rules contained in O 6 and O 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O 4, r 1.) The particulars of infringement shall be included in a plaint as stated in O 7, r 1 and shall:
(1) indicate the particulars of infringement and when it happened. It should clearly show which of the claims in the specification have been infringed and should give one example of the infringement alleged. The defendants shall have full and fair notice of the case they have to meet. (See Batley v Kynock (No 2) (1874-75) LR 19 Eq 229, pp 231-32.) (2) contain the facts showing the court has jurisdiction. (3) end with the relief, which may be simple or in the alternative, and include, both interim and final relief. (4) contain a statement of the value of the suit for the purpose of jurisdiction and of court fees. (5) be accompanied by documents on which the plaintiff sues or relies. (Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O 7, r 14.) (6) show ownership of the patent and that the patent is in force.
7The particulars of infringement must be specific. The manner, in which the defendant committed the infringement, if known, must also be pleaded. (See Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Co v Ati Atlas Ltd [2001] FSR 31.) A manufacturer of goods can be expected to know the details of infringement more than a seller of goods. The particulars of infringement must be more detailed when the action is targeted against a person who will have no technical knowledge of the patent, like a seller of goods. (See Mandleberg v Morley (1893) 10 RPC 256, p 260.) Though the right to initiate an action for infringement accrues after the grant, a patentee may sue with regard to infringing acts committed after the date of application is published. The plaint must allege an actionable infringement or else the claim will be struck out. (See Schuster v Hine Parker & Co Ltd (1935) 52 RPC 345, p 352.) A threat to infringe is sufficient to base an action. (See Bloom v Shulman (1934) 51 RPC 308.) But a patentee cannot base its action on allegations speculative in nature. (See Upjohn Co v T Kerfoot & Co Ltd [1988] FSR 1, p 8, where the court observed that it would be desirable to plead allegations of copying.) The plaintiff will not be required to give better particulars if he has put forward the best particulars available. (See Intel Corpn v General Instrument Corpn [1989] 1 FSR 640, p 646.)
8A plaint may be rejected if: it does not disclose the cause of action; a relief is undervalued; plaint is insufficiently stamped; the suit is barred by any law; plaint is not filed in duplicate; or plaintiff fails to serve adequate copies of the plaint under O 7, r 9. (Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O 7, r 11.)
9In Hindustan Lever v Lalit Wadhwa (2007), on an application to reject the plaint in a patent suit, the Delhi High Court held that “While dealing with an application under Rule 11 of Order 7, in order to decide whether the plaint discloses any cause of action or not, the Court has to examine only the allegations made in the plaint and the documents filed with it. Where the allegations made in the plaint, prima facie, disclose a cause of action, the plaint cannot be rejected.” (para 5) It held that the phrase “does not disclose the cause of action”, as used in Order 7 Rule 11(a), “has to be very narrowly construed”, and that “This power of rejection of the plaint ought to be used only when the court is absolutely sure that the plaintiff does not have an arguable case at all.” (para 11) For that purpose, it held, “the averment that the plaintiff has a valid patent and that the defendant is infringing the patent of the plaintiff have to be assumed to be true.” (para 12) In Geobrugg v Techfab (India) Industries (2026) the Himachal Pradesh High Court held, on the authority of the Supreme Court, that “at the time of considering application under Order VII, rule 11 CPC, only contents of plaint as well as documents relied upon can be taken into consideration but certainly, in no eventuality, averments contained in the written statement or documents relied upon by the defendant can be taken into consideration. The test is as to whether if the averments made in the plaint are taken to be correct in their entirety, a decree would be passed.” (para 20)
10In Geobrugg the Himachal Pradesh High Court agreed with counsel “that non-joinder of parties cannot be a ground for rejection of plaint”, and held on Order I, rule 9 and Order I, rule 13 of the Code that “it becomes clear that no suit shall be defeated by reason of misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, and the court may deal with the matter in controversy regarding the rights and interests of the parties actually before it.” (para 32)
11The defendant shall file the written statement within the stipulated time and shall produce the documents upon which he relies. (Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O 8, rr 1 and 1A.) The written statement shall contain all the grounds of defence, details of specific denial and the reasons for denial, things he puts the plaintiff to strict proof and the things he admits. (Ibid, O 8, r 2.) (Ibid, O 8, rr 3 and 5.) However, where an application for interim relief is pending soon after the institution of the suit, the defendant cannot be expected to disclose his full defence. But in practice, the defendants are known to file elaborate statements questioning the validity of the patent and denying infringement, both of which cannot be determined before full trial. (Smith (TJ) & Nephew Ltd v 3M United Kingdom Plc (1983) RPC 92, p 103 (CA).)
12On the written statement in a suit on a standard essential patent, in Dolby International v Lava International (2025) the Delhi High Court held that “Lava’s experts failed to disclose any alternate technology adopted by Lava to implement the standard. Rule 3(B)(vi) of the Delhi High Court Rules Governing Patent Suits, 2022 clearly mandates that the implementor has to disclose the details of the alternate technology adopted by the implementor to implement the standards. The burden to prove the alternate technology cannot be shifted by Lava to Dolby.” (para 80) In InterDigital Patent Holdings v Shenzhen Transsion Holdings (2026) the same Court found that “the defendants had not furnished any details with regard to any alternate technology that might have been used in the products, which appears to be in contravention of Rule 2(f) of the High Court of Delhi Rules Governing Patent Suits 2022. Equally, the written statement does not appear to be specific in terms of the requirement of Rule 2(d) and Rule 3B(ii) & (vi) of the Rules, 2022.” (para 85)
13The defendant may raise grounds of revocation as a counter-claim against the plaintiff either before or after the filing of the suit, but before the defendant has delivered his defence or before the time limited for delivering his defence has expired. (Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O 8, r 6A(1).) A ground of revocation which the defendant raises as a counter-claim must be specifically stated in the written statement. (Ibid, O 8, r 6B.) The counter-claim shall have the same effect as a cross-suit. (Ibid, O 8, r 6A(2).) Such a counter-claim will be treated as a plaint and shall be governed by the rules applicable to plaints. (Ibid, O 8, r 6A(4).)
14In Communication Components Antenna v Mobi Antenna Technologies (Shenzhen) (2022) the Delhi High Court held that “The applicant - seeking revocation of a patent - has the onus to explain in its pleadings as to how the claim construction renders it liable for revocation”, and that “a party seeking revocation of a patent - must allege and show insufficiency of disclosure and specifically point out such deficiency and/or inadequacies in the patent specifications. Pertinently, while assessing the sufficiency of disclosure, the patentee should be afforded an opportunity to demonstrate that the ground of revocation is not sustainable on facts by leading evidence, and thus arises the requirement of specific pleadings.” (para 12) Where the issue of insufficiency had been framed but neither pleaded nor proved, it held that “since the additional issue was premised on a question of fact, it was necessary for the Defendant to make a specific pleading to that effect and lead evidence in support thereof. In the absence of such pleadings and no evidence having been led in this case, this Court cannot conclusively hold that IN240893 is insufficiently disclosed.” (para 14)
15The defendant will be permitted to introduce, by way of an amendment, a new ground of defence by way of a counter-claim which may arise after the institution of the suit or the presentation of the written statement. (Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O 8, r 8. See Vax Appliances Ltd v Hoover Plc (1990) RPC 656.)
16The plaintiff must specifically reply to the counter-claim of revocation, as a default on the part of the plaintiff in putting a reply to the counter-claim may result in the court pronouncing a judgment against the plaintiff in relation to the counter-claim made against him. (Code of Civil Procedure, O 8, r 6E.) A reply to a counter-claim will be treated as a written statement and shall be governed by the rules relating to written statement. (Ibid, O 8, r 6G.)
High Court of Delhi·5 August 2014
High Court of Delhi·4 February 2022
High Court of Delhi·10 April 2023
High Court of Delhi·10 July 2025
High Court of Himachal Pradesh·6 May 2026
High Court of Delhi·7 September 2026
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/pleadings