Case page

Intex Technologies (India) Ltd v Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ) (2023)

High Court of Delhi·Manmohan & Saurabh Banerjee JJ·Division Bench·Decided 29 March 2023·2023:DHC:2243-DB; 2023 SCC OnLine Del 1845

Good law Intex's appeal FAO(OS)(COMM) 296/2018 dismissed and Ericsson's cross-appeal FAO(OS)(COMM) 297/2018 allowed; Intex directed to pay the entire royalty to Ericsson within four weeks, in place of the 50% payment and 50% bank guarantee ordered on 13 March 2015. No further appeal traced as of 27 October 2026. Interlocutory

A Standard Essential Patent holder may obtain interim relief against an unwilling licensee; Intex's admissions defeated its validity challenge, its appeal failed, and full interim royalty was ordered.

Cite this page

Intex Technologies (India) Ltd v Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ), Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/intex-ericsson

Judgment PDF

Summary

“Present cross-appeals have been filed challenging the judgment and order dated 13th March, 2015, hereinafter referred to as the ‘impugned order’, passed by the learned Single Judge” (para 2). By that order, Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson v Intex Technologies (India) (2015), “the learned Single Judge has held that Ericsson’s eight suit patents were prima facie valid, essential and that Intex has prima facie infringed Ericsson’s patents.” (para 3) “Ericsson has filed FAO(OS)(COMM) No.297/2018 seeking modification of the impugned order” “whereby the learned Single Judge has directed Intex to pay 50% royalty at the interim stage and balance 50% by way of a bank guarantee. Ericsson prays that Intex be directed to pay the entire royalty amount.” (para 4) “Since Standard Essential Patent is a relatively new species of patent, it is necessary to define it as well as propound the test of infringement in such cases and explain the importance of standards.” (para 39)

The Bench held that “Standard Essential Patent owners who file lawsuits can pray for interim and final injunctive relief if an infringer is deemed by a Court to be an ‘unwilling licensee,’” (para 91) and that “the four-fold test in Nokia vs. Oppo (supra) is neither applicable at Order 39 Rule 10 CPC” (“Code of Civil Procedure”) “stage nor at Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC stage.” (para 117) It found that “prima facie the suit patents are essential, have been infringed and the royalty sought by Ericsson is on FRAND” (“Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory”) “terms. Further, Intex is prima facie an intentional unwilling licensee and it has failed to raise a credible challenge to the validity of the suit patents.” (para 149) “Accordingly, the appeal of Intex being FAO(OS)(COMM) 296/2018 is dismissed while the appeal filed by Ericsson being FAO(OS)(COMM) 297/2018 is allowed and Intex is directed to pay the entire royalty amount to Ericsson within four weeks.” (para 151)

What the court decided

  1. What a Standard Essential Patent is. “Keeping in view the aforesaid as well as the fact that TRAI” (“Telecom Regulatory Authority of India”) “has directed telecommunication companies to comply with ETSI” (“European Telecommunications Standards Institute”) “standards, this Court is of the view that the term ‘Essential’ in the facts of the present case means that a patent is essential to a standard i.e. it is not possible on technical grounds to comply with the standard without infringing the patent. This Court is of the opinion that this simple definition is adequate in many circumstances like the present one but not all. Consequently, a Standard Essential Patent is ‘a patent claiming technology that is essential to an industry standard’s use’.” (para 60)
  2. The holder’s obligations. “Standard Essential Patents are treated differently from non-Standard Essential Patents- in at least in one respect i.e., the rights of a patentee in case of a Standard Essential Patents are circumscribed by its contractual commitment made to a SSO/SDO” (“Standard Setting Organizations”, “Standard Development Organisations”) “to make the patent available to all those who are willing licensees while the term of the patent is subsisting. Consequently, Intellectual Property Rights Policies of SDOs usually impose at least the following obligations on Standard Essential Patent holders:” “(i) The duty to disclose relevant patents as being Standard Essential Patents. (ii) The duty to make available the Standard Essential Patents to all those who are willing to use it, and not to withhold access. (iii) The duty to offer licences to all willing licensees on FRAND” (“Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory”) “terms.” (para 61)
  3. Obligations of both sides. “If the licensor offers a supra-FRAND offer i.e. exorbitant royalty rates, it will not be considered a willing licensor.” (para 69) “Similarly, an implementer has no right of silence or inaction at this stage.” (para 70) “Further, the implementer has to either accept the licensor’s offer or give a counter offer along with an appropriate security in accordance therewith to prove its bonafides as in the interregnum it cannot freely sell its devices using such Standard Essential Patents.” (para 72) “The Standard Essential Patents regime incorporates mutual reciprocal obligations on both the Essential Patent holder and the implementer. It is not a ‘one way street’ where obligations are cast on the Essential Patent holder alone.” “This Court is also of the view that the conduct of the parties during negotiations is one of the key factors to be kept in mind while assessing whether a potential licensor and licensee were a willing licensor or a willing licensee. The said finding is normally fact sensitive.” (paras 69–70, 72–73)
  4. Standard Essential Patents in Indian law. “Although Standard Essential Patents are not spoken of in the Patents Act, 1970, decisions of this Court have long recognized this concept, and have adjudicated claims for infringement, security and damages etc.” (para 74) “The Delhi High Court’s Rules Governing Patent Suits 2022 have formally recognized Standard Essential Patents and the different legal tests that are involved in their adjudication.” (paras 74–75)
  5. Injunction against an unwilling licensee. “The argument on behalf of Intex that the Court should not grant an injunction or pass a direction to pay, since the Standard Essential Patent owner’s only interest is in obtaining reasonable royalties, an interest which can be fully recognised by an award of damages at the end of the trial is untenable in law.” (para 76) “Consequently, though in Unwired Planet v Huawei (supra), the UK Supreme Court did not grant an injunction until after the FRAND trial, yet this Court is of the view that the Courts can and should do so before the trial.” (para 85) “This Court is also of the view that one will have to adapt foreign jurisprudence with respect to Standard Essential Patent keeping in view the Indian realities, in particular, the fact that the judge-population ratio is extremely poor in this country and expeditious disposal of patent suits cannot be expected at the cost of other suits.” (para 90) “Keeping in view the aforesaid as well as the fact that there is no prohibition in Indian law against a Standard Essential Patentee from seeking an injunction, this Court is of the view that Standard Essential Patent owners who file lawsuits can pray for interim and final injunctive relief if an infringer is deemed by a Court to be an ‘unwilling licensee,’ often as indicated by the use of ‘stalling’ and other opportunistic bargaining and litigation tactics.” (paras 76, 85, 90–91)
  6. The test of infringement. “Consequently, the test for infringement in the case of an unwilling licensee of a Standard Essential Patent would have to be satisfied at the prima facie stage.” (para 92) “There is the direct test of infringement which is applied in all standard patent cases. The other is the indirect method which involves proving the following steps:” “(i) Mapping patentee’s patent to the standard to show that the patent is a Standard Essential Patent. (ii) Showing that the implementer’s device also maps to the standard.” (para 93) “To show that the patent maps on to the standard (A=B), courts take into consideration ‘claim charts’, which show that the claims of a patent are also present in the technical features of a standard.” (para 95) “However, this is not a necessary requirement, as most devices declare their compliance with a given standard.” (para 96) “This Court is of the opinion that Delhi High Court Patent Rules and International jurisprudence are unanimous in holding that the ‘indirect’ method is a sure shot and better method of proving Standard Essential Patent infringement and essentiality.” (paras 92–96, 98)
  7. Infringement of one patent. “This Court is of the view that an injunction can be secured, even if the infringement of one patent is established either prima facie, or at the final stage.” (para 99) “Accordingly, if a case for infringement, even with regard to one patent, is made out, it is like a ‘silver bullet’.” (para 103) “Consequently, to restrain an infringing device, a Standard Essential Patent holder does not have to sue based on each of the thousands of patents that it claims to own in the product; it can do so by showing that one, or a handful of representative patents are infringed.” (paras 99, 103–104)
  8. Portfolio licences. “Consequently, as value is in the technology which forms a part of the standard and the suit patents is just representative of that technology, Ericsson is not required to offer individual patent licences or country specific licences and that global portfolio licences are capable of being FRAND.” (para 111)
  9. The four-fold test. “Consequently, the test formulated in Nokia Vs. Oppo (supra) that no amount can be paid unless the four factors mentioned therein are fulfilled, is not borne out from Unwired Planet v Huawei (supra)” (para 113). “In the opinion of this Court, the four-fold test casts an onerous burden upon the Standard Essential Patentee and that too at the interim stage itself. In fact, the said burden is completely alien to the patent jurisdiction and does not apply even in normal patent suits.” (para 115) “Moreover, if the four-fold test stipulated in paragraph 77 of the Nokia Vs. Oppo (supra) is applied, then effectively there will be no interim order like a temporary injunction or conditional order of deposit in the Standard Essential Patent suits. Such a view, in the Court’s opinion, would be contrary to Section 48 of Patents Act, Code of Civil Procedure as well as Standard Essential Patent regime which is aimed at achieving a uniform standard in technologies.” (paras 113, 115, 117)
  10. The interim inquiry. “Consequently, at the stage of seeking interim relief, the Court must consider the relief sought in the case from a prima facie perspective. This means that the Court must assess whether prima facie, the patent is infringed. The Court must also assess prima facie, whether the implementer is an unwilling licensee and/or whether the royalty sought by the plaintiff is on FRAND terms i.e. whether globally or locally similar implementers are paying royalty in accordance with the terms suggested by the patentee.” (para 118)
  11. Admissions of essentiality. “In the present case, Ericsson’s claims of essentiality of its patents and infringement by Intex are admitted facts.” (para 119) “This Court is also of the view that invocation of the jurisdiction of CCI” (“Competition Commission of India”) “, which is premised on the presumption of essentiality, implementation and dominance of Ericsson’s patents, shows that Intex was very well aware that it was infringing the suit patents.” (para 121) “Moreover, if Intex was of the view that it was not infringing Ericsson’s patents and the same were non-essential, Intex instead of approaching CCI alleging abuse of dominant position, should have sought a declaration of non- infringement or of groundless threat under Sections 105 and 106 of the Act.” (para 122) “In view of the aforesaid admissions by Intex as well as lack of any material to even raise a prima facie doubt, this Court is of the opinion that there was no need for the learned Single Judge to examine as to whether the test of” “essentiality and/or infringement as stipulated in Fujitsu v Netgear Inc. (supra) is fulfilled or not.” (paras 119, 121–122, 127)
  12. A pending revocation petition. “Insofar as issue of validity is concerned, this Court is of the view that once a patent is granted, it is for the person challenging the validity of the registered patent to raise a credible challenge.” “This vulnerability has, however, to be demonstrated by way of a credible challenge and not solely on the ground that a revocation petition has been filed and is pending. Consequently, the onus was on Intex to establish the credibility of the challenge raised by it. The challenge cannot be incredible, fanciful or moonshine. After all, the fact that an Inventor has been granted a patent by the Patent Office after scrutiny, although initially, has to be given due weightage.” (para 129) “Further, the submission that the onus to prove the validity of the suit patents is on the plaintiff as there can be no presumption of validity of a patent in view of combined reading of Sections 13(4), 64 and 107 of the Patents Act, 1970, is untenable in law” (para 132). “Consequently, just because a revocation petition had been filed by Intex, does not mean that it has to be presumed that Ericsson’s patents are prima facie invalid. Mere filing of a revocation petition is not sufficient in itself.” (paras 129, 132, 138)
  13. Dominance and invalidity. “This Court is further of the view that it is counter-intuitive for a party alleging abuse of dominance to claim that the patents are invalid as there cannot be dominance let alone abuse thereof qua patents which are invalid.” (para 136) “Accordingly, this Court is in agreement with the argument of learned counsel for Ericsson that there is no legal embargo which prevents a Court from reaching a finding of lack of a credible challenge on the basis of admissions made by parties.” (paras 136–137)
  14. Section 8. “This Court is in agreement with the aforesaid prima facie findings and is of the view that Intex has failed to show how Ericsson has deliberately suppressed any information relevant under Section 8 of the Act from the Patent Controller.” (para 139) Following “the Division Bench in” Merck Sharp and Dohme Corporation v Glenmark Pharmaceuticals (2015), “after considering the judgment in” Chemtura Corporation v Union of India (2009), that “Defendant is obligated to demonstrate how the breach of Section 8 provision is ‘patent and manifest’. Without such evidence, the breach of Section 8 of the Act cannot be made the” “sole ground for non-grant of interim injunction.” (para 141) “Consequently, the argument by Intex of a ‘Strict liability’ test for non- compliance of Section 8 is contrary to law” (para 142). “But this Court is of the view that a new plea which was not considered by the learned Single Judge in its judgment cannot be raised to contend that the learned Single Judge has erred in interpreting Section 8 of the Act.” (para 143) “Consequently, no prima facie breach of obligation under Section 8(2) of the Act is made out.” (paras 139, 141–144)
  15. Section 3(k) and prior art. “This Court is of the view that only a bare-bone challenge with respect to Section 3(k) of the Act has been stated in the written statement filed by Intex.” (para 145) “This Court is in agreement with the aforesaid prima facie finding of the learned Single Judge.” (para 146) “There was also no specific challenge qua lack of novelty and inventive step in the written statement filed by Intex. In fact, there is no reference to prior art in written statement much less a plea meeting the test of Section 64 of the Act.” (para 147) “Consequently, Intex has failed to raise a credible challenge to the validity of the suit patents.” (paras 145–148)
  16. Appellate interference. “Consequently, this Court is of the opinion that Intex has failed to satisfy the principle of law laid down by the Supreme Court in Wander Ltd. & Anr. v. Antox India Pvt. Ltd. 1990 (Supp.) SCC 727 inasmuch as it has not been able to show how the learned Single Judge has exercised its discretion in a manner which was arbitrary, perverse or capricious and not in conformance with the law.” (para 149)
  17. Full royalty on the cross-appeal. “However, this Court finds merit in the appeal filed by Ericsson as the fact that the telecom industry has overwhelmingly accepted Ericsson’s Standard Essential Patents cannot be disregarded. In fact, more than one hundred licences have been executed by Ericsson for the same technology globally and similar implementers are paying royalty in accordance with the terms suggested by Ericsson.” “Ericsson are prima facie FRAND terms and to ensure parity with other implementers, Intex must pay in full for the past use of the Standard Essential Patents.” (para 150) “Accordingly, the appeal of Intex being FAO(OS)(COMM) 296/2018 is dismissed while the appeal filed by Ericsson being FAO(OS)(COMM) 297/2018 is allowed and Intex is directed to pay the entire royalty amount to Ericsson within four weeks.” (paras 150–151)

What the court did not decide

“This Court clarifies that the observations made by it are prima facie in nature and the learned Single Judge shall dispose of the suit finally without being influenced by any of the observations made by this Court.” (para 151)

Subsequent treatment

  • Followed — In Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson v Lava International (2024) the Delhi High Court held that “The two-step test for establishing infringement of SEPs” “has been laid down by the US Court of Appeals in Fujitsu (supra) and has been approved by the Division Bench of this Court in Intex (supra)” (para 617).
  • Followed — In InterDigital Patent Holdings Inc v Shenzhen Transsion Holdings Co Ltd (2026) the Delhi High Court, reading this judgment, held that “the learned Division Bench unequivocally held that the SEP regime primarily balances the equities between the SEP holders and the implementers, purely to ensure a level playing field” (para 24).

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cases this judgment relies on

Cited in

Case page · Page updated 22 November 2026

www.aop.onl/intex-ericsson