Doctrine page

Conditions Precedent to a Section 105 Suit

What are the conditions precedent to a suit for a declaration of non-infringement?

A suit under section 105 lies only where the plaintiff has applied in writing with full particulars and the patentee has refused or neglected to give such an acknowledgement.

Doctrine last updated on 22 November 2026

Cite this page

Conditions Precedent to a Section 105 Suit, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/section-105-conditions

1In an action for a declaration of non-infringement, there should be a written description of the matter in respect of which the declaration is sought. The description is crucial in a proceeding where the patentee has made a pre-action acknowledgement and the declaration sought for was made in respect of the written description. If the defendant is able to show that the written description embraced processes in which infringement could have taken place, then even if that description also embraced processes in which infringement could not have taken place, it would be a strong case for rejection of declaration. (Niche Generics Ltd v Lundbeck [2004] FSR 20, [2003] EWHC 2590 (Pat Ct).) But if the plaintiff in the action for the declaration of non-infringement succeeds in showing that the process used in manufacture is no different from that forming the subject matter of the declaration, then the action of infringement instituted by the defendant would stop. (Ibid.)

2It is always preferable to present the full written particulars together with a sample or drawings of the alleged infringement to the patentee. (Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Co’s (Suspension Aerosol Formulation) Patent (1999) RPC 135, p 153.) A declaration of non-infringement can be made only if the plaintiff had clearly and unambiguously described its product, so that no product falling within that description could reasonably be taken to infringe the claims of the patent. (MMD Design & Consultancy Ltd’s Patent (1989) RPC 131 (Pat Off). Following Mallory Metallurgical Products Ltd v Black Sivalls and Bryson Inc (1977) RPC 321(CA), it was held that the drawing coupled with the description in the letter was fully adequate for the determination, although the letter alone was not.) Where the relevant article is not produced before the court, either as a sample or a drawing, it may be difficult for the court to issue a declaration, if the description was capable of referring to more than one article. The Court of Appeal has elucidated the requirements of such description, in the following words: (Mallory Metallurgical Products Ltd v Black Sivalls and Bryson Inc (1977) RPC 321, p 339 (CA) per Goff LJ. In this case, the declaration sought for was refused by the lower court and the consequent appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal. The case involved a declaration of non-infringement under s 66 of the UK Patents Act 1949.)

I think there may be a question of construction arising on section 66 (of the Patents Act 1949) as to whether it is necessary for the applicant to produce an actual embodiment of the article and identify it, but it is not necessary for us to decide that question, and we have not heard argument about it, at any rate from the respondents, and I prefer to express no view on the point one way or the other. I will also assume, without deciding, that the description required by the section may describe more than one article; but it is abundantly clear that if there is before the court no actual article, and if the description is capable of referring to more than one article, the description must be completely precise and such as will enable the court to say no article corresponding to that description could infringe the patent.

3The plaintiff should apply in writing to the patentee for a written acknowledgement. The written acknowledgement may be in any form, provided it seeks the patentee to give an acknowledgment that the acts done or proposed to be done by the plaintiff do not amount to an infringement of the patent. In the Lipitor infringement case, Ranbaxy had filed an application for a declaration of non-infringement, after an acknowledgment was refused by the patentee, Warner-Lambert. (Ranbaxy UK Ltd v Warner-Lambert Co [2006] FSR 14 (Pat Ct).) An extract of the letter seeking acknowledgment read as follows:

Our client is considering whether to manufacture and/or import and/or sell atorvastatin calcium in the UK upon expiry of the data package exclusivity attaching to that pharmaceutical. The purpose of this letter is to ensure that our client’s path is sufficiently cleared of patent issues prior to considering a launch and is sent pursuant to section 71 of the (UK) Patents Act 1977. Our client requires acknowledgement from you that any acts including; manufacture, keeping, importing for disposal, sale and any other acts of the kind mentioned in Section 60 of the (UK) Patents Act 1977 and done in the United Kingdom would not constitute infringement of any of the claims of the ‘633 patent (European Patent (UK) 0247633). (Ibid. The declaration of non-infringement sought for by Ranbaxy was refused.)

4The plaintiff would normally write to the patentee where it anticipates a threat of infringement action. Conversely, the patentee may initiate action to avoid giving a written acknowledgement. In one instance, the patentee instructed its solicitors to write a number of warning letters to the major customers of the plaintiff, informing them of the patentee’s patents, as a result of which the customers removed the plaintiff’s product from sale. (Siegfried Demel v C&H Jefferson [1999] FSR 204 (Pat Ct).)

5Two limbs of the section do not turn on the patentee’s conduct. The suit lies “notwithstanding that no assertion to the contrary has been made by the patentee or the licensee”, so a threat of infringement proceedings is no part of the cause of action (Patents Act 1970, s 105(1)). And the suit “may be brought by virtue of this section at any time after the publication of grant of a patent”, the references in the section to the patentee being construed accordingly (ibid, s 105(4)).

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

See also

Doctrine page

Declaratory Relief Under the Specific Relief Act

Can declaratory relief in a patent matter be sought under the Specific Relief Act?

Doctrine page

Validity Is Not in Issue Under Section 105

Can a patent's validity be challenged in a suit for a declaration of non-infringement?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/section-105-conditions