Principles of Claim Construction
How do Indian courts interpret the claims of a patent?
Latest update: . Case: Indian Network for People living with HIV/AIDS v Union of India. Doctrine: Appeals in Compulsory Licensing.
On what date is a patent specification construed — its priority date or the date of publication?
A specification under section 10 is construed with reference to the state of the art at the time it is published, different dates being attributed for different purposes.
Doctrine last updated on 19 November 2026
The Relevant Date for Construction, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/date-of-construction
1The courts have deliberated, with differing opinions, on what should be the relevant date for construing a specification. The relevant date for determining insufficiency has been held to be the date of filing the application, the date of acceptance of specification, the date of filing of complete specification and the date of publication. (See Standard Brands Inc’s Patent (No 2) (1981) RPC 499, pp 529-31 (CA). See also Osram Lamp Works Ltd v Popes Electric Lamp Co Ltd (1917) 34 RPC 369; Anxionnaz v Rolls Royce Ltd (1967) RPC 419; American Cyanamid Co (Dann’s) Patent (1970) RPC 306, p 329; Illinois Tool Works Inc v Autobars Co (Services) Ltd (1974) RPC 337.) Generally, a specification is construed with reference to the state of the art at the time it is published. (See Lane-Fox v Kensington and Knightsbridge Electric Lighting Co Ltd (1892) 9 RPC 413, p 417, [1892] 3 Ch 424, pp 427-28. See also Standard Brands Inc’s Patent (No 2) (1981) RPC 499, p 529 (CA).) The Court of Appeal has held that under the UK Patents Act 1977, a ‘patent specification must be construed as at the date of its publication’. (Willemijn Houdstermaatschappij BV v Madge Networks (1992) RPC 386, p 388.) This is in variance with some decisions where it has been observed that the patent should be construed with regard to its priority date. (See Helitune Ltd v Stewart Hughes Ltd (1991) RPC 78, [1991] FSR 171, p 206 where Aldous J observed: ‘I believe that the correct approach is to look first to see what are the acts of the defendant which are alleged to be infringements and which it wishes to continue. Thereafter I must decide whether it carried out those acts in good faith before the priority date or whether it made effective and serious preparations to do so.’ See also Glaverbel SA v British Coal Corpn (1995) RPC 255, p 284, [1995] FSR 254.) There appears to be a practice of attributing different dates for different purposes. In fact, in Biogen Inc v Medeva Plc, the House of Lords held that the relevant date for assessing sufficiency under s 72(1)(c) of the UK Patents Act (for the purpose of determining validity of a patent) is the date of application and not the date of publication of specification. ((1997) RPC 1, p 54.)
2When the principles of interpretation of patent applied are the same for determining invalidity (revocation) and infringement, the variance in the manner of ascertaining the relevant date with regard to the construction of a specification creates difficulties. The differing perspectives appear to be the result of differing standards in determining the state of the art for the purposes of novelty, obviousness and sufficiency. It is submitted that it would be anomalous to regard the date of publication as the date at which the state of common general knowledge has to be assessed for the purposes of construction, since obviousness has to be assessed in the light of common general knowledge at the priority date. It would also be anomalous to separate the date at which sufficiency has to be assessed from the date at which the specification has to be construed. (See Sundstrand Corpn v Safe Flight Instrument Corpn [1994] FSR 599, p 607, following Willemijn Houdstermaatschappij BV v Madge Networks (1992) RPC 386.)
How do Indian courts interpret the claims of a patent?
What counts as the common general knowledge of the person skilled in the art?
When can a patent be revoked for insufficient disclosure in India?
Can a defendant in an infringement suit argue that the patent is invalid?
How is the priority date of a claim in an Indian patent application determined?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/date-of-construction