Appeals from the Controller
Can an order of the Patent Controller be appealed to the High Court?
Latest update: . Case: Indian Network for People living with HIV/AIDS v Union of India. Doctrine: Appeals in Compulsory Licensing.
Which compulsory licensing orders of the Controller can be appealed under the Patents Act?
An appeal lies to the High Court under section 117A(2) from the Controller's compulsory licensing orders, but an order under section 92A cannot be the subject matter of an appeal.
Doctrine last updated on 19 November 2026
Appeals in Compulsory Licensing, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/compulsory-licence-appeals
1Article 31(i) of the TRIPS Agreement provides for judicial review of decisions granting compulsory licences. Before the abolition of the Appellate Board, section 117B provided for an appeal from the decision of the Controller to the Appellate Board of orders passed under ss 84(1) to (5), 85, 88, 91, 92 and 94. It is submitted that the references to sub-ss (1) to (5) of s 84 are misleading as an order is passed only under s 84(4) which can be the subject matter of an appeal. The appeal now lies to the High Court, as s 117B stands omitted by the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021 (w.e.f. 4 April 2021), and s 117A(2) provides that “An appeal shall lie to the High Court from any decision, order or direction of the Controller” under, among other provisions, “sub-sections (1) to (5) of section 84, section 85, section 88, section 91, section 92 and section 94” (Patents Act 1970, s 117A(2), as amended by the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021).
2It is important to note that an order passed by the Controller under s 92A cannot be the subject matter of an appeal under the Patents Act. Such orders can be judicially reviewed by exercising the writ jurisdiction of the high courts. The right to appeal from a decision of the Controller would exist regardless of whether the patentee opposed the application. (See Zanetti-Streccia’s Patent (1973) RPC 227, [1972] FSR 507.)
Can an order of the Patent Controller be appealed to the High Court?
Is Chapter XVI a complete code on abuse of patent rights?
What is the procedure on an application for a compulsory licence under section 84?
Does an appeal under the Patents Act lie to the IPAB or to the High Court?
Can a Patent Office order be challenged in a writ petition before a High Court?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/compulsory-licence-appeals