A tender issued from Delhi gave part of the cause of action, and the defendant's prior revocation petition drew the infringement suit to the same Court: plaint not returned.
Summary
“The Plaintiffs have filed the present Suit under Section 48 read with Section 109 of the Patents Act, 1970” (“Act”) “seeking permanent injunction, infringement of patent and rendition of accounts with regards to patent bearing Patent No. IN284904 titled ‘Sectional Construction Assemblies’” (para 1). Before the suit, “the Defendant in April 2023 filed a Revocation Petition bearing C.O. (COMM. IPD-PAT) No. 4/2023” “under Section 64 of the Act” (para 2). The defendant applied “under Order VII Rules 10 and 11 read with Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908” (“CPC”) “seeking rejection / return of the Plaint” (para 3), and the plaintiffs applied “under Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the CPC seeking amendments to the Plaint.” (para 8)
The Court framed the question as “whether the Plaint, as originally instituted, disclosed any cause of action, wholly or in part, within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court.” (para 12) It held that “the origin of the tendering authority, AAI” (“Airports Authority of India”) “being in Delhi, establishes a partial cause of action within the meaning of Section 20(c) of the CPC” (para 14), and that “a conjoint reading of Sections 64 and 104 of the Act indicates that the same Court, which is deciding the Revocation Petition should also decide the Suit for infringement.” (para 15) The defendant’s application “is hereby dismissed as the Plaint sufficiently discloses the cause of action within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court” (para 19), and the plaintiffs’ application “for seeking amendment of Plaint is allowed.” (para 20)
What the court decided
- Procedure. Reading the plaint. “It is settled law that for the purposes of an application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC” (“Civil Procedure Code, 1908”), “the averments contained in the plaint alone are required to be examined to determine if the Plaint discloses cause of action” and, following Saleem Bhai and Mayar (H.K.) Ltd., “the plaint must be read as a whole.” (para 13)
- A tender issued from Delhi. “Referencing Ayodhya Airport in the Plaint was sufficient as the Tender for the same was issued by AAI” (“Airports Authority of India”) “having office in Delhi.” “Although the execution of the Ayodhya Airport project was outside Delhi, the origin of the tendering authority, AAI being in Delhi, establishes a partial cause of action within the meaning of Section 20(c) of the CPC.” (para 14)
- A revocation petition filed first. “In view of the proviso to Section 104 of the Act and the decision in Aloys Wobben (supra), where the defendant sought revocation, it would not be permissible to raise the counter claim in the suit for infringement. As the Defendant has instituted the Revocation Petition on 10.04.2023 prior to filing of the present Suit, it would not be permissible for the Defendant to raise a counter claim in the present Suit. Accordingly, a conjoint reading of Sections 64 and 104 of the Act indicates that the same Court, which is deciding the Revocation Petition should also decide the Suit for infringement. Accordingly, this Court has jurisdiction to entertain the present Suit.” (para 15)
- Quia timet averments. “Furthermore, quia timet principles as held in Allied Blenders & Distillers Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and Shilpa Medicare Ltd. (supra) are applicable to the facts of the present case as the Plaint contains foundational averments indicating imminent or credible threat of infringement within Delhi.” (para 16)
- Procedure. Amendment of the jurisdictional pleading. The proposed amendments “introducing the facts regarding the location of the AAI in Delhi, issuance of tenders from Delhi, the contractual chain involving entities in Delhi, and the alleged participation of the Defendant in a proposed project namely, Khyber, have the foundation already existing in the Plaint. Hence, the amendments sought by the Plaintiffs are clarificatory in nature and necessary for determining the real controversy between the Parties.” (para 17) They “do not alter the nature of the Suit or introduce a new cause of action” (paras 17–18)
- Disposition. The defendant’s application “under Order VII Rules 10 and 11 of the CPC filed by the Defendant is hereby dismissed as the Plaint sufficiently discloses the cause of action within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court and, therefore, the Plaint cannot be rejected or returned under Order VII Rule 10 or Rule 11 of the CPC.” (para 19) The amendment application “is allowed. The amended Plaint is taken on record. The Defendant is granted liberty to file amended Written Statement in the Suit within a period of four weeks from date.” (paras 19–20)
Subsequent treatment
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 17 October 2026.