Conditions Precedent to a Section 105 Suit
What are the conditions precedent to a suit for a declaration of non-infringement?
Latest update: . Case: InterDigital Patent Holdings Inc v Shenzhen Transsion Holdings Co Ltd. Doctrine: Conditions Precedent to a Section 105 Suit.
Can declaratory relief in a patent matter be sought under the Specific Relief Act?
The bar imposed by section 105 is limited only to a declaration of non-infringement, and other declaratory relief may be sought under section 34 of the Specific Relief Act 1963.
Doctrine last updated on 22 November 2026
Declaratory Relief Under the Specific Relief Act, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/declaratory-relief
1The general power to seek a declaration with regard to any legal character or any right as to any property is contained in s 34 of the Specific Relief Act 1963. Section 34 reads as follows:
- Discretion of court as to declaration of status or right.—Any person entitled to any legal character, or to any right as to any property, may institute a suit against any person denying, or interested to deny, his title to such character or right, and the court may in its discretion make therein a declaration that he is so entitled, and the plaintiff need not in such suit ask for any further relief:
Provided that no court shall make any such declaration where the plaintiff, being able to seek further relief than a mere declaration of title, omits to do so.
*Explanation.— A trustee of property is a ‘person interested to deny’ a title adverse to the title of someone who is not in existence, and for whom, if in existence, he would be a trustee.
2Ordinarily, any person will have the power to approach the court for a relief of declaration under s 34 of the Specific Relief Act 1963. Though the power of the court under s 34 is not exhaustive, an express mention of s 34 in the non obstante clause of s 105 will have the effect of overriding the same. (Vemareddi Ramaraghava Reddy v Konduru Seshu Reddy AIR 1967 SC 436; Supreme General Films Exchange Ltd v His Highness Maharaja Sir Brijnath Singhji Deo of Maihar AIR 1975 SC 1810.)
3Reference to s 34 of the Specific Relief Act 1963 does not have the same implication as the reference to ‘court’s jurisdiction to make a declaration’ under s 71 of the UK Patents Act 1977. In the United Kingdom, the provisions of s 71 do not interfere with the ability of the court to make a declaratory judgment in its inherent jurisdiction. (Filhol v Fairfax (Dental Equipment) Ltd (1990) RPC 293, p 308.) In fact, the experience in United Kingdom shows the liberal manner in which relief under the court’s inherent jurisdiction was granted in cases where strict compliance with s 71 of the UK Act could not come to the rescue of the plaintiff. (Ibid; Chiron Corp v Evans Medical Ltd [1996] FSR 863.)
4There is a marked difference between the comparative provisions of the Patents Act and the United Kingdom Act. Section 105 of the Patents Act begins with a non obstante clause. It reads ‘Notwithstanding anything contained in section 34 of the Specific Relief Act 1963’. Whereas s 71 of the UK Act employs the phrase ‘Without prejudice to the court’s jurisdiction to make a declaration or declarator apart from this section.’ A non obstante clause differs significantly from a ‘without prejudice’ clause. A provision enacted ‘without prejudice’ to another provision means that the said provision must neither be inconsistent with nor prejudicial to the other provision. (GP Singh, Principles of Statutory Interpretation, tenth edn, 2006, p 341. See ITO v Gwalior Rayon Silk Manufacturing (Weaving) Co Ltd AIR 1976 SC 43, p 47.) Thus, when one provision is ‘without prejudice’ to another provision, the recourse to one provision does not bar the use of the other after abandoning the one which was resorted to earlier. On the other hand, the provision following a non obstante clause will have its full operation and the provisions embodied in the non obstante clause will not be an impediment for its operation. Thus, the non obstante clause in s 105 which specifically refers to s 34 of the Specific Relief Act 1963 will have the effect of setting aside anything contained in s 34 which is inconsistent with s 105.
5The bar imposed by s 105 is limited only to a declaration of non-infringement. A person interested in a patent will be entitled to seek a declaratory relief, on matters other than non-infringement under s 34 of the Specific Relief Act 1963. Under s 34 of the Specific Relief Act 1963, the plaintiff need not ask for any further relief. However, the court shall not make any declaration where the plaintiff, being able to seek further relief than a mere declaration of title, omits to do so. It will be interesting to see whether the fact that a plaintiff could seek a further relief of revocation of a patent would disentitle the plaintiff a relief under s 34.
6The power of the court to make a declaration is discretionary." (Supreme General Films Exchange Ltd v His Highness Maharaja Sir Brijnath Singhji Deo of Maihar AIR 1975 SC 1810. For a detailed commentary on the discretion of the court to grant a declaratory relief under s 34 of the Specific Relief Act 1963, see Pollock & Mulla, Indian Contracts and Specific Relief Acts, twelfth edn, 2001,vol 2, p 2740.) “For seeking a decree of declaration, the plaintiff should establish the following four conditions:
(1) The right of the plaintiff—that the plaintiff is entitled to any legal character or any right as to property; (2) The infringement—that the defendant is denying or is interested to deny the plaintiff’s title or such legal character or right;
(3) The declaration—that the declaration sought is that the plaintiff is entitled to such legal character or right; and (4) The consequential relief—that where the plaintiff is able to seek further relief than mere injunction, he seeks such relief. (Pollock & Mulla, Indian Contracts and Specific Relief Acts, twelfth edn, 2001,vol 2, pp 2692- 2693.)
7The same discretion has been applied to a declaration sought under Article 226 of the Constitution. In Novartis v Union of India (2007) the Division Bench of the Madras High Court, relying on Supreme General Films Exchange and on Vaish Degree College v Lakshmi Narain, recorded that “the relief of declaration under the provisions of the Specific Relief Act is purely discretionary”, and that “while exercising it’s discretionary powers, the court must keep in mind the well settled principles of justice and fair play and should exercise the discretion only if the ends of justice require it, for justice is not an object which can be administered in vacuum”. It found that “ends of justice, on the facts of this case, is not in favour of the petitioner, which would disable us from exercising our discretionary jurisdiction”, applying the rule that “no declaration would be given where it would serve no useful purpose to the petitioner”. The Court gave two reasons. “It is a settled position in law that nobody can compel the Parliament to enact a Law”; and though “a declaratory relief could be granted, provided, it is shown that such a declaratory relief would be a stepping stone to claim relief at some other stage”, here “the declaratory relief, even if granted, would be only on paper, on the basis of which, the petitioner cannot claim any further relief in the Indian courts”. (para 9)
8The courts will be reluctant to make a declaration on hypothetical facts and would presume that there is no cause of action where the defendant has not asserted any right. (Wyko Group v Cooper Roller Bearings [1996] FSR 126 (Copyright case).) The express prohibition against including questions of validity of a patent in a suit for non-infringement under s 105 will not apply to a declaration under the Specific Relief Act 1963, as there is no bar to make a separate claim of revocation in the same suit. (See the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O II, r 3.)
What are the conditions precedent to a suit for a declaration of non-infringement?
Can a patent's validity be challenged in a suit for a declaration of non-infringement?
Can a Patent Office order be challenged in a writ petition before a High Court?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/declaratory-relief