Doctrine page

Validity Is Not in Issue Under Section 105

Can a patent's validity be challenged in a suit for a declaration of non-infringement?

The making or refusal of a declaration under section 105 shall not be deemed to imply that the patent is valid or invalid, validity not being called in question.

Doctrine last updated on 22 November 2026

Cite this page

Validity Is Not in Issue Under Section 105, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/section-105-validity

1More often, a relief for a declaration of non-infringement is coupled with a relief for revocation of the patent. (See Ranbaxy UK Ltd v Warner-Lambert Co [2006] FSR 14 (Pat Ct); Kirin-Amgen Inc v Hoechst Marion Roussel Ltd [2005] 1 All ER 667 (HL).) English law holds the issues of validity and infringement as part of the same questions, as it is not possible to infringe an invalid claim. (Organon Teknika Ltd v Hoffmann-La Roche AG [1996] FSR 383, p 386. See also Reckitt & Colman Products Limited v Biorex Laboratories Limited [1985] FSR 94 (Pat Ct).) But a suit under s 105 of the Patents Act shall not, in any way, affect the validity of a claim in a patent. The validity of a claim shall not be called into question in such a suit. (Patents Act 1970, s 105(3).) Section 105(3) reads, that the validity of a claim of the specification of a patent shall not be called in question in a suit for a declaration brought by virtue of this section, and accordingly the making or refusal of such a declaration in the case of a patent shall not be deemed to imply that the patent is valid or invalid. In other words, the mere fact that an existing process or a product does not amount to infringement does not necessarily mean that the patent already granted is invalid. The validity of a patent after the grant can be questioned only on the grounds available under s 64. Thus the making or refusal of a declaration under s 105 shall not be deemed to imply that the patent is valid or invalid. In certain cases the court may order separate trial on the issue of infringement, if some of the defendants have taken an application to that effect, on the condition that those defendants withdraw their allegations of invalidity. (Jerome Canady v Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH [2005] EWHC 2946 (Pat Ct). The case involved an infringement action over the sale of flexible probes intended for endoscopic application of the argon plasma coagulation technique. It was held that one of the defendants was entitled to the declarations of non-infringement in relation to the probes, including those for use in bronchoscopes, which they have not yet introduced with the jurisdiction of the court.) Where the court holds that the patent should be revoked, a declaration of non-infringement will not be granted. (Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Co’s (Suspension Aerosol Formulation) Patent (1999) RPC 135, p 153.)

2Section 105 of the Patents Act differs from s 71 of the UK Patents Act 1977 on the issue of questioning the validity of a patent in a suit for declaration of non-infringement. Section 74(1)(c) of the UK Act makes it clear that the validity of a patent may be put to issue in a proceeding under s 71 of the UK Act. But the distinction may be irrelevant in the Indian context as a separate claim for revocation can be made by the plaintiff in the same suit. (See the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O II, r 3, which enables the plaintiff to unite in the same suit several causes of action against the same defendant.) The Act itself provides that no suit for a declaration under s 105 “shall be instituted in any court inferior to a district court having jurisdiction to try to suit”, and “where a counter-claim for revocation of the patent is made by the defendant, the suit, along with the counter-claim, shall be transferred to the High Court for decision” (Patents Act 1970, s 104). It is more likely that the defendant will counter-claim for infringement in a suit for declaration of non-infringement, to which the plaintiff would, in turn, claim for revocation of the patent. (Mayne Pharma Ltd v Debiopharm SA [2006] EWHC 1123 (Pat).) Despite the bar imposed by s 105, a decision on the issue of validity would be essential, as a declaration of non-infringement ought not to be made in respect of an invalid patent. (See Pittevil & Co v Brackelsberg Melting Processes Ltd (1932) 49 RPC 23 (CA); Martinez’s Patent [1983] RPC 307, p 312 (Pat Off).)

3The counter-statement of the defendant should clearly indicate the reasons for withholding the declaration. Where the counter-statement did not make it clear the reasons for withholding the declaration, the patentee must amend its counter-statement and clearly establish a case of infringement. (Wollard’s Patent (1989) RPC 141, p 145 (Pat Off). In this case, the counter-statement of the patentee did not disclose whether a declaration of non-infringement should be withheld in respect of (a) boats having a narrow keel flat, (b) boats having a stepped transom, and (c) boats having both a narrow keel flat and a stepped transom. The patentee was required to amend his counterstatement to indicate specifically in each case what characteristics and functions of the narrow keel flat and stepped transom led to the infringement of the patent.) If the defendant is not clear whether the process employed by the plaintiff infringes its patent, it may ask for an inspection of the same. (Niche Generics Ltd v Lundbeck [2004] FSR 20, [2003] EWHC 2590 (Pat Ct).) Similarly, the defendant can require further details of the product in issue to be furnished by the plaintiff before giving an acknowledgement. Normally when a suit for declaration of non-infringement is filed by the plaintiff, the defendant will make a counter claim for infringement. (Mayne Pharma Pty Ltd v Pharmacia Italia SPA [2005] EWCA Civ 137 (CA).) The defendant may also seek a counter-claim for a declaration that the plaintiff’s products did infringe the patent. (Chiron Corp v Evans Medical Ltd [1996] FSR 863 (Pat Ct).) If the patentee gives an acknowledgement of non-infringement based on the existing information and subsequently finds out that the products of the plaintiff actually infringed its patent, it may counterclaim for infringement of that patent. (Mayne Pharma Pty Ltd v Pharmacia Italia SPA [2004] EWHC 2458 (Ch).)

4The burden of proving non-infringement is on the person who seeks such declaration. (Rohm & Haas Co v Collag Ltd [2002] FSR 28, [2001] EWCA Civ 1589 (CA); Mallory Metallurgical Products v Black Sivalls and Bryson Inc (1977) RPC 321, p 345 (CA) per Scarman LJ followed in Rohm & Haas Co v Collag Ltd [2001] FSR 28 (Pat Ct).) When the defendant counter-claims infringement, the burden of proving infringement is on the defendant, which may shift to the plaintiff in cases involving a patented process. (Patents Act 1970, s 104A.)

5The plaintiff shall bear the cost of all the parties to the suit unless the court provides otherwise taking special reasons into consideration. (Ibid, s 105(2).) In cases involving a declaration of non-infringement of a process, if the court feels that an inspection of the process employed by the plaintiffs is of substantial evidential importance to test the question of infringement, the court may allow inspection of such process. The plaintiffs will be entitled to their costs in respect of such inspection. (Niche Generics Ltd v Lundbeck [2004] FSR 20, [2003] EWHC 2590 (Pat Ct).)

6It is possible for a defendant in an infringement suit to raise the issue of declaration of non-infringement by way of a counterclaim. (Vax Appliances Ltd v Hoover Inc (1990) RPC 656 (Ch D).) The defendant, in an infringement suit, may amend its counterclaim to ask for a declaration as an alternative to the revocation of the patent. Such amendments will require the leave of the court. The court would grant leave to amend the counterclaim even though the counterclaim as amended will have to rely on a cause of action which did not exist at the date when the counterclaim was first made. (Ibid, p 661.)

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

See also

Doctrine page

Declaratory Relief Under the Specific Relief Act

Can declaratory relief in a patent matter be sought under the Specific Relief Act?

Doctrine page

Invalidity as a Defence

Can a defendant in an infringement suit argue that the patent is invalid?

Doctrine page

Conditions Precedent to a Section 105 Suit

What are the conditions precedent to a suit for a declaration of non-infringement?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/section-105-validity